What should be the maximum number of guild members?

ArchivedUser

@foghladha  Your great thread has diverged from the intent to quite a range of opinions and discussions off topic, with not many people actually stating how many is the right balance from their opinion.

https://forums.ashesofcreation.com/discussion/33592/please-dont-punish-casuals-with-small-guild-caps-intrepid/p1

Perhaps to see what the general consensus is; a poll to see what people think?

What should be the maximum number of players permitted in one guild?

ArchivedUser

I put 100 but my vote would be 200

ArchivedUser

Are we talking about the size limit that all guilds can unlocked up to in the guild-leveling system based on what Steven had previously said? 

ArchivedUser

Definitely just figured out how to vote twice LOL so a 100 and 300 = 200

ArchivedUser

My vote's on 300, since i don't think a larger guild would be manageable xD

WinterAssassin said:

Definitely just figured out how to vote twice LOL so a 100 and 300 = 200

wut? how did you do that? xD

ArchivedUser

I might be able to answer this after testing. Right now it's too early to put numbers on things.

ArchivedUser

think 100 good enough as there will be alliance and so on also  might like to see differnt guild sixes on different servers as a guild of 50 can be on the same server as a guild of 300 plus an off branch guild of 100

ArchivedUser

Arkanth said:

My vote's on 300, since i don't think a larger guild would be manageable xD

WinterAssassin said:

Definitely just figured out how to vote twice LOL so a 100 and 300 = 200

wut? how did you do that? xD

It's a skill, you have to reach my level to acquire it

ArchivedUser

Is this actual character players, with alts counting as a player, or is it account wide (including alts). 
1 player with 8 alts, 
or 
8 alts = 8 players

ArchivedUser

lexmax said:

I might be able to answer this after testing. Right now it's too early to put numbers on things.

I have no logic to warrant a certain number over another, but my understanding of Ashes is that it will encourage folks to cooperate outside of the guilds so I suspect the numbers won't be too high.    

ArchivedUser

Although I prefer smaller guilds I think for the "guild choices for small guild benefits or larger numbers" we need a slightly large guild option. 300 is fair imo so blocks of 50 tiers. Stage 1 50 > 300 stage 6. Anything larger than that I don't think is really necessary ^^

ArchivedUser

The max number will be whichever on the developers decide on. Heh heh. It matters little to me how big other guilds are UNLESS it causes a significantly unfair advantage that is detrimental to my game play.