Glorious Alpha Two Testers!

Phase I of Alpha Two testing will occur on weekends. Each weekend is scheduled to start on Fridays at 10 AM PT and end on Sundays at 10 PM PT. Find out more here.

Check out Alpha Two Announcements here to see the latest Alpha Two news and update notes.

Our quickest Alpha Two updates are in Discord. Testers with Alpha Two access can chat in Alpha Two channels by connecting your Discord and Intrepid accounts here.

Will AoC graphics be able to handle the test of time?

KoreKodeKoreKode Member
edited August 2020 in General Discussion
Just finished watching the Allcraft youtube video Featuring Rich, Asmongold and Summit1G and they made a very good Observation about the graphics of AoC versus some other MMO's

AoC have what looks like photo realistic graphics and compared to wow with there more cartoony grpahics wich have held up for the past 15 plus years. I'm not sure if Realistic Graphics can do the same thing. With wow it was probably much easier and way less taxing on computers to upgrade the look of those graphics where as for the graphics of AoC it would probably take much more work and much more processing power to handle upgrading those graphics. So can AoC graphics handle 15+ years like wows did?

Whats your thoughts?

Again everyone this is just for Discussion sake! this isn't a bash towards the game or anything like that. I just felt the Observation was a good one and thought I'd get others opinions. Regardless of gameplay or mechanics or anything else.
«1

Comments

  • rodzorrodzor Member, Braver of Worlds, Alpha One, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    Well in 15+ years we will all be inside a simulation or realize we are already in one so... But yea I think they mentioned they will be able to upgrade UE4 to the next-gen UE when the time comes. Right now they are probably just worried about getting the game ready for launch and not that far into the future, also this is all assuming this game will still be relevant when that time comes. They could release a different game all-together by then, I know they have other games they are working on right now that are not going to be announced until AoC is released.
  • rodzor wrote: »
    Well in 15+ years we will all be inside a simulation or realize we are already in one so... But yea I think they mentioned they will be able to upgrade UE4 to the next-gen UE when the time comes. Right now they are probably just worried about getting the game ready for launch and not that far into the future, also this is all assuming this game will still be relevant when that time comes. They could release a different game all-together by then, I know they have other games they are working on right now that are not going to be announced until AoC is released.

    if it will be as easy as just upgrading to future releases of UE that would be great but something tells me it won't be that easy.

    I'm sure they are very worried about the future of this game even now during Alpha phases. Don't get me wrong i'm not knocking the way AoC looks. its just those graphics will get old they will start to look horrible in the years to come and you know what, if the game runs great and the combat feels good and the content is fun and plentiful the graphics won't matter as much but there will come a point where it will wear on people and they will want it to look better in some ways even if its just better water textures or something small. Everyone will find something they think could have looked a little better even if JUST a little. Doesn't mean its going to ruin the game.

    But look at the game for how it will most likely look come release. Will those graphics alone for discussion sake be able to handle the test of time? My opinion is No but if the gameplay and content is good it still won't ruin the game.
  • WoW looked like crap in Alpha too though. We know how that turned out.
    zZJyoEK.gif

    U.S. East
  • KoreKodeKoreKode Member
    edited August 2020
    Yuyukoyay wrote: »
    WoW looked like crap in Alpha too though. We know how that turned out.

    I understand the game is in Alpha. I'm not basing it off of how it looks right now. I'm basing the question off how it will most likely look come release with the Photo realistic art style it is going with. and just for discussion sake.
  • Crysis still looks amazing. How old is it now?
  • rodzorrodzor Member, Braver of Worlds, Alpha One, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    You can only get so close to realistic until it finally becomes real...
  • doford wrote: »
    Crysis still looks amazing. How old is it now?

    Compare the original Crysis to say Battlefield 4 or the newest COD? its showing its age. Even the newest Crysis is showing its age versus some of these games. Not to the point that I don't want to play it but I feel an MMO is going to hurt more then say a FPS that you can play and beat in several hours.
  • rodzor wrote: »
    You can only get so close to realistic until it finally becomes real...

    Exactly!

    so lets say AoC took a different approach to their art style and went more WOW style. Would it help it last the test of time longer? would the graphics matter less to you because they are cartoony and not realistic?
  • I really dont care about graphics at all.. Gameplay is everything for me. And its the most important part.
  • Marcet wrote: »
    I really dont care about graphics at all.. Gameplay is everything for me. And its the most important part.

    I agree 100%
  • NeliryaNelirya Member, Founder, Kickstarter, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    edited August 2020
    I personally can't stand the graphics of WoW and am very pleased with the graphical direction AoC seems it taking. Gameplay is vital, of course, but WoW graphics just ruined the game for me.
    giphy.gif
  • Marcet wrote: »
    I really dont care about graphics at all.. Gameplay is everything for me. And its the most important part.

    They either matter or they don't for people. There are games like OSRS that have graphics that wouldn't even impress someone 20 years ago and the game still has a healthy and growing playerbase. But when asking my friends to play the game with me the #1 reason given for not playing is the graphics.

    So while I don't think the graphics will make or break the game I still think they are somewhat important. With that said, even the graphics in their present form would not present a problem.
  • Beck AltarrBeck Altarr Member, Alpha One, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    In 10+ years AoC's graphics will look cartoony. It will become part of its charm.
    phoenix.png
    Alpha/Beta Tester of Many Games - Station Manger of PhoenixRadio.Online an AoC & Gamer themed online Radio. Tune In Here
    Love a good story and lore.
    Twitch Streamer : PRO Discord
  • lunarskylunarsky Member, Braver of Worlds, Kickstarter, Alpha One, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    No, they won't stand up for 15 years. There is not a single game in existence that's graphics have stood up that long. No, not even WoW and it's cartoony style. Gameplay makes or breaks MMOs. If people can still play Runescape, EQ, L2 etc and enjoy it even now they can do the same with AoC. If you think about it Minecraft is really popular but if we looked at it's graphics they're not good. Call it style choice or whatever you like they aren't impressive in any way compared to what is possible with today's technology but people play the hell out of that game. They can always upgrade the graphics if they want to down the line. Technology moves too quickly to make a game that graphically keeps up with processing power a decade and a half later. It's just the way it is.
    Future Py'rai (M) - Shaman, Enchanter, Soul Weaver, Templar, or Necromancer (Pending)
    Future Crafting Plans: Herbalism > Alchemy & Scribe or Mining > Metalworking > Jewel cutting (Pending)
  • AtamaAtama Member, Braver of Worlds, Kickstarter, Alpha One, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    It’s true that no game will hold up in 15 years. Pick the best-looking game of 2005 and compare it to new releases heralded for their graphics and it will fall flat.

    But if the game is fun and has longevity then it won’t matter. Here is what happens with “classics”...

    1) There is something about the game that hooks people and makes it successful. It could be graphics, or story, or innovative gameplay, maybe it’s even the first entry in a new genre of games that spawns imitators. It is also likely to produce sequels.

    2) After a while it stops being a novelty, and maybe its popularity wanes, but it still maintains a diehard fanbase who may keep playing it long after it stops being considered the hot new thing.

    3) Eventually whatever made the game successful in the first place is really dated and there have been other games since which have surpassed it, because as technology advances we have opportunities to make games do more and do it better, and we can build on past success to teach us how to make superior games. But still, people will look at the game with nostalgia and it will maintain a following, maybe even attract new fans drawn to playing a “retro classic”.

    Look at Mass Effect. The graphics blew people away in 2007 when it came out. Looking at them today, they aren’t awful but they’re definitely mediocre and if someone launched a new game that relied on equivalent graphics to attract players it would flop. But many people consider it one of the best games they ever played (me included) and will probably never think of it as a bad game even though objectively “better” games are being made now.

    Or Pac-Man. Who even cares what the graphics look like? That’s a classic forever.
     
    Hhak63P.png
  • mrwafflesmrwaffles Member, Leader of Men, Kickstarter, Alpha One, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    TBH I still play older MMOs from time and time again and where YES the graphics don't blow me out of the water I still love them. Now, do new players come and join probably not. This didn't answer the original question so I contributed nothing (story of my life)
    E6qgOoi.png
  • SongcallerSongcaller Member, Alpha One, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    If/When they upgrade to UE5 ( UE5 is gorgeous ) I will build a new pc to run UE5 and all the ray tracing goodies UE5 would bring. I have no need to upgrade for UE4 and I appreciate the dedication and direction of Ashes.
    2a3b8ichz0pd.gif
  • TaranissTaraniss Member, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    Like it has been stated. No game actually stands the test of time graphics wise. Even WOW has not. It is the gameplay and even the community to an extent that keeps games going.
    a34ad54277341e048554a1bf88ee6284.jpg

    Heroes Fade but Legends last forever

  • ArellaArella Member, Phoenix Initiative, Royalty, Kickstarter, Alpha One, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    Graphics dont need to stand up. They are what they are in and of themselves. Earthbound looks and plays like it does, Morrowind looks and plays like it does, WoW looks and plays like it does. The only question you need to ask yourself is do you enjoy playing it and will you enjoy playing it still in 15 years. Updates to the content and avoiding the dumbing down of the gameplay or oversaturation of microtransactions will determine that for better than the graphics,
    𝙿𝚛𝚊𝚒𝚜𝚎 𝚋𝚎, 𝚝𝚑𝚎 𝙰𝚗𝚌𝚒𝚎𝚗𝚝 𝙶𝚘𝚍𝚜
  • PlagueMonkPlagueMonk Member
    edited August 2020
    About WoW... the reason why WoW's graphics were done the way they were was 1) To run on as many computers as humanly possible. So they had to make the poly count fairly low to run on a fairly crappy system. 2) So they wouldn't have to worry as much about aging. Choosing a style means you don't have to compete to keep up with 'realistic'. They did however have a refresh/upgrade a while ago to improve the poly count but they still run on the lowest common denominator systems for the time.

    Like it or hate it, the creators made some very smart decisions that have made them a ton of cash.

    Interesting thing about 'realistic' and MMOs is, just like buying a computer system, the moment you commit to it, it's outdated. When it releases in 2 years it will be using graphics that are 4-5 years out of the current. That's the way of all games but especially MMOs because of the much longer development cycle.
    Marcet wrote: »
    I really dont care about graphics at all.. Gameplay is everything for me. And its the most important part.

    I both agree and disagree with you. Be honest, would you really like AoCs graphics to look like say the original EQ?! I bet not so you have to care about them a little ;) That said however I personally am drawn in BY the graphics initially, but as I play the game a switch happens. Graphics become less important while the gameplay becomes the most important thing, at least for me. If the game does still look good though, I might actually be caught off guard by a beautiful vista while running somewhere and have to stop and look for a couple moments :)
    isFikWd2_o.jpg
  • AtamaAtama Member, Braver of Worlds, Kickstarter, Alpha One, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    edited August 2020
    PlagueMonk wrote: »
    That said however I personally am drawn in BY the graphics initially, but as I play the game a switch happens. Graphics become less important while the gameplay becomes the most important thing, at least for me.
    That was one of the main points of my earlier post. Graphics might spur you to try out the game but it will only become a classic if it keeps you playing, and the greatest games stay great despite the graphics becoming outdated.
     
    Hhak63P.png
  • PlagueMonk wrote: »
    I both agree and disagree with you. Be honest, would you really like AoCs graphics to look like say the original EQ?! I bet not so you have to care about them a little ;) That said however I personally am drawn in BY the graphics initially, but as I play the game a switch happens. Graphics become less important while the gameplay becomes the most important thing, at least for me. If the game does still look good though, I might actually be caught off guard by a beautiful vista while running somewhere and have to stop and look for a couple moments :)

    You have good points. For me, the game already looks too good. I would say graphics can attract a bit of interest but its more about the design of weapons, architecture, map and char modeling what makes the game and not "texture quality". If the design is good Its gonna hook you with bad textures. Once im into a game the graphics have 0 importance, It's called inmersion.

    Graphics does not equal inmersion.

    A book has no images and the inmersion is brutal.
  • lunarsky wrote: »
    No, they won't stand up for 15 years. There is not a single game in existence that's graphics have stood up that long. No, not even WoW and it's cartoony style. Gameplay makes or breaks MMOs. If people can still play Runescape, EQ, L2 etc and enjoy it even now they can do the same with AoC. If you think about it Minecraft is really popular but if we looked at it's graphics they're not good. Call it style choice or whatever you like they aren't impressive in any way compared to what is possible with today's technology but people play the hell out of that game. They can always upgrade the graphics if they want to down the line. Technology moves too quickly to make a game that graphically keeps up with processing power a decade and a half later. It's just the way it is.

    That's what im talking about!

    Why is the conversation "Are the graphics gonna last 15 years" and not "Will the gameplay and comunity last 15 years"?

    Why is people even worried about graphics??
  • nidriksnidriks Member, Warrior of Old, Kickstarter, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    KoreKode wrote: »
    Just finished watching the Allcraft youtube video Featuring Rich, Asmongold and Summit1G and they made a very good Observation about the graphics of AoC versus some other MMO's

    AoC have what looks like photo realistic graphics and compared to wow with there more cartoony grpahics wich have held up for the past 15 plus years. I'm not sure if Realistic Graphics can do the same thing. With wow it was probably much easier and way less taxing on computers to upgrade the look of those graphics where as for the graphics of AoC it would probably take much more work and much more processing power to handle upgrading those graphics. So can AoC graphics handle 15+ years like wows did?

    Whats your thoughts?

    Again everyone this is just for Discussion sake! this isn't a bash towards the game or anything like that. I just felt the Observation was a good one and thought I'd get others opinions. Regardless of gameplay or mechanics or anything else.

    I don't think the graphics need to hold up with time. Like you, say only WoW has really lasted and I believe Blizzard made a concious choice of going with less realistic graphics to make the game easier to upgrade and more able to last.

    Consider EQ. It was the first full 3D MMO, but the graphics look shocking now. People do still play EQ, of course. If Ashes stands the test of time then I will happily still play it in 2042.
  • PatchPatch Member, Alpha Two
    I think we are at a point where today's photo realistic graphics are good enough to last many years into the future.

    I agree with the others that have said gameplay > graphics (and by a large margin)
  • You can't look at WoW today and say that it has held up all these years though, because it doesn't look the same today as it did at launch. Check out some comparison videos of it.

    AoC can make improvements later on during the game's life just like WoW did. While I'm no expert, I think the fact that they are using UE might help in that regard.

    Also, I play FFXIV, which isn't "photo realistic", but it's nowhere near the kind of design WoW has. It's basically a 10 year old game that got remade 7 years ago (same engine etc, not much different graphics wise). Think it's basically a 15 year old engine at this point, at least. It still looks good enough for me, and it will continue for many years probably. They haven't even really made much changes to it since launch (think the engine is very limited compared to UE).

    I don't see why AoC would be any different if they do it right.
  • PatchPatch Member, Alpha Two
    edited August 2020
    Atiqa wrote: »
    You can't look at WoW today and say that it has held up all these years though, because it doesn't look the same today as it did at launch. Check out some comparison videos of it.

    I know this is not a debate WoW graphics thread, but this is just wrong. WoW looks very different (yet similar within it's style) than it did upon release. They have added so many polygons and smoothed out just about every model and terrain in the game.

    I agree with you. FFXIV still looks lovely. I sometimes wish there were more contrast in their color scheme, but it feels wonderful to adventure through Eorzea.

    Edit: I read your post incorrectly. we're on the same page! sorry!

  • Patch wrote: »
    Atiqa wrote: »
    You can't look at WoW today and say that it has held up all these years though, because it doesn't look the same today as it did at launch. Check out some comparison videos of it.

    I know this is not a debate WoW graphics thread, but this is just wrong. WoW looks very different (yet similar within it's style) than it did upon release. They have added so many polygons and smoothed out just about every model and terrain in the game.

    I agree with you. FFXIV still looks lovely. I sometimes wish there were more contrast in their color scheme, but it feels wonderful to adventure through Eorzea.

    Edit: I read your post incorrectly. we're on the same page! sorry!

    Yes I 100%, agree with mostly everyone that obviously the "classic" graphics of wow were improved upon in the last 15+ years to help it hold up. Plus combat animation were also improved and things like that. I believe AOC could also do this with the upgrade to UE5. Who knows the possibilities!

    I think that's the great thing about AOC being made now! Its got so much more possibilities with new engines and with all the people involved in making this game.

    I like how everyone has great opinions here and I think talking about something as simple as this (and this could sound corny) will help us all realize what we enjoy and cherish in a mmo at its core as a community. We might see it differently but in the end we all want a great mmo to play.

    Ashes will look different in 15+ years just like wow did
  • rodzorrodzor Member, Braver of Worlds, Alpha One, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    edited August 2020
    I play Realm of the Mad God all the time, it is literally a pixel game and it's fun as hell to me. Graphics don't make a game good imo. If the gameplay and community stand the test of time the game could last 10-15 years easily.
  • @KoreKode

    Every game will age. Even WoW ages, you can notice it in the diff between the texture of newer and older gear and in the detail of newer and older zones as well.

    As long as the new content that is added into the game is on par with game graphics of its time, it won't matter as much.
Sign In or Register to comment.