Greetings, glorious testers!

Check out Alpha Two Announcements here to see the latest news on Alpha Two.
Check out general Announcements here to see the latest news on Ashes of Creation & Intrepid Studios.

To get the quickest updates regarding Alpha Two, connect your Discord and Intrepid accounts here.

Cultural Immersion, Inclusivity, and Representation in Verra

SevarielSevariel Member, Alpha Two
edited October 30 in General Discussion
Hey everyone,

I've been reflecting on the vibrant community we’re building here and the potential for Verra to feel truly immersive.

Since this world is shaped by and for its community, I think there’s value in discussing how to make it feel like home to everyone who's passionate about the game and it's core philosophies, as creatively and naturally as possible.

Intrepid clearly intends to celebrate cultural diversity within Verra. Ashes has already previewed race-based armor, architecture, and aesthetics, which adds a lot of depth and variety to the world. I hope to see many immersive concepts that showcase each race’s unique traditions, languages, and celebrations.

Heritage-Specific Quests and Artifacts
Quests and artifacts that reveal the unique histories, superstitions, and even rivalries between Verrans of ages past. For instance, a Py’rai player might uncover a hidden artifact that offers insight into a legendary conflict with the Vaelune, which is inaccessible to other races without assistance. This could create a cooperative dynamic where players of different races team up to unlock secrets and understand the full story behind Verra’s past conflicts and alliances. It would encourage diverse party compositions and create bonds through shared knowledge.

Cultural Lorebooks and Libraries
Each race could maintain libraries or lorebooks with cultural records and teachings, with some materials written in their native language and available only to members of that race. Other players might need to earn enough trust to access these libraries, with lorebooks containing vital clues or quests. This could create a sense of reverence and mystery around each race’s history, customs and beliefs. Players could team up to unlock deeper lore, sparking conversation and encouraging curiosity about each race’s ancestral values and past.

Identity Representation
As always, doesn’t need to be loud or even central. It can be as simple as acknowledging that LGBTQ+ people also exist within Verra, in the same understated way that love and companionship are acknowledged in many fantasy realms, just as in real life. No one’s ancestry, identity or loved ones should be viewed as a statement or a form of virtue signaling. Rather, I see it as an opportunity for Intrepid to walk the walk on inclusivity by allowing players from all walks of life to feel truly seen and a part of in this world we’re all so excited about.

Cultural Festivals
Festivals throughout the year, each with its own traditions, dances, decorations, and even mini-games or event quests. For instance, the Py’rai could have a festival celebrating the spirits of the forest and Shol, while the Nikua might celebrate a festival honoring the tides and their ancestors. Festivals would pull players to various "ancestral lands," not just to watch but to participate in unique activities that could reward rare cosmetics, boosts, or knowledge. This may foster respect and camaraderie, making each race’s heritage feel relevant to the whole of Verra.

We'll obviously share a common tongue, but it's also fun and immersive through a role-playing lens when each race has its own secondary language that only players of that race can read or communicate with. NPCs that reference customs, histories, and beliefs specific to their people, would make each biome and interaction feel more distinct and alive.

I’m curious if others feel that some subtle gestures toward inclusivity—however small—could make Verra feel like a more welcoming place for everyone who wants to call it home. Maybe it’s an NPC or a small nod in the lore; maybe it’s nothing at all. I’m here for all perspectives.

I’d love to hear honest thoughts from the community on this, no matter where you stand. Let’s keep it warm, reflective, and respectful. After all, it’s the ability to discuss the diversity of our perspectives that makes us stronger in Verra and beyond.
«1

Comments

  • OriazaelOriazael Member, Alpha Two
    I really like the idea of passive representation. I’m interested in having cultural growth with your character. Expanding on your artifact example, it’d be cool to raise your reputation with certain races and earn rewards like unique traits, recipes/schematics, languages, mounts, transmogs, and emotes exclusive to that race.

    You could even gain access to specific quests that initiate you as an honorary member of that race. Then, NPCs from that race could start giving you subtle nods of acknowledgment through gestures or dialogue, which could either change the overall outcomes or just add immersion to your interactions. Man, I'm getting hyped to play again this weekend lol.
  • VerusVerus Member, Alpha Two
    Representation of in-lore races, classes, and regions? Great.

    Divisive and de-immersive representation of real-world identity politics and reflections of modern events? Unwelcome and directly fracturing to the community in their separate world of Verra. Allow them some escapism and peace.
  • SevarielSevariel Member, Alpha Two
    edited October 29
    Verus wrote: »
    Divisive and de-immersive representation of real-world identity politics and reflections of modern events? Unwelcome and directly fracturing to the community in their separate world of Verra.

    Thanks for sharing your perspective.

    I do think it’s a bit of a stretch to frame someone’s existence as ‘political’ or a reflection of ‘modern' events. Inclusivity isn’t about mirroring real-world identity politics in a forced way; it’s about creating a world that feels rich, nuanced, and welcoming to all kinds of people, reflecting the diversity that exists in reality—even in fantasy settings. It’s worth noting that Ashes has already confirmed the inclusion of same-sex marriages in Verra, which aligns with the inclusive spirit of the game.

    This isn’t a call for explicit or divisive themes, and I certainly don’t expect Verra to be decorated in rainbows during Pride Month (though a giant rainbow for an hour every day in June would be rad, now that I think about it).

    Ultimately, I think creating a space where diverse players feel seen enriches the community and adds depth to Verra in a way that enhances immersion rather than detracting from it. I'm not sure who you're referring to here:
    Allow them some escapism and peace.
    I think everyone who is in for AoC's core systems and the long-term survival of the game deserves some escapism and peace. :smile:
  • novercalisnovercalis Member, Founder, Kickstarter, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    in-game related stuff, sure. Not ingame related, no, i dont want woke culture in my game. keep IRL politics out of my game.
    {UPK} United Player Killer - All your loot belongs to us.
  • SevarielSevariel Member, Alpha Two
    novercalis wrote: »
    in-game related stuff, sure. Not ingame related, no, i dont want woke culture in my game. keep IRL politics out of my game.

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts! Could you clarify what you mean by 'woke culture and IRL politics' and how the ideas mentioned above might impact the game for you?

    It’d be helpful to understand your perspective so we can keep the conversation productive and focused on what makes Verra immersive and enjoyable for everyone.
  • NikbisNikbis Member, Alpha Two
    Identity representation?

    No.

    Christian church and its influence & way of thinking -that anything and everything is a sin- over the centuries is what ultimately led to the need for an LGBT community to form & express a unified voice to correct wrong doings.
    Before that, anyone could be gay, lesbian or whatever whitout repercussion.
    Even trans to some extent. They obviously didn't have the technology we now have yet they had ways. Could raise some eyebrows at the time I assume but nothing more.

    If no church or dogma used that kind of repression back there in Sanctus or in Verra, then there's no need for any of more "inclusivity" or "representation", nor do you need to "feel truly seen" or "welcomed" more than anybody else (you really tried to check the buzz-words don't you?). People can already feel and express themselves without constraint.

    Considering all that's happening with DEI stuff currently in videogaming, you'd only antagonize people by pushing this kind of things out of nowhere and geopardise the future of AoC, rightfully so.


    I was writing a post somehow related to that subject about the character creator.

    I don't think there's a game where you can create a character that ranges from skinny -kinda like a walking bag of bones- to big dudes.
    By "big dudes" I'm thinking of Sig Curtis from Fullmetal Alchemist, Thor's representation of God of War, or even Gragas from League of Legends.
    5p4c1jqy0uhx.jpg
    That's the kind of Character editor I'd like to see. Diversity in body proportions.

    Then I thought about how you can edit your character's appearence later on in MMORPGs, for a small fee (money has to come from somewhere), and how awesome it'd be to see that transition over time.
    Say, again, from skinny to Thor. You adjust the sliders to your liking, you get a before/after look of your character, maybe a sped-up simulation of the trantition, and the time it require to take effect in-game, with a bare minimmum of like 1 month for the more drastic changes.

    From there, you can esealy make trans characters without having to shove the IRL term on players faces.
    Currently, you choose your character as either "masculine" or "feminine". You turn that into a slider from "0 - masculine" to "1 - feminine", with 0.5 being androgynous. When you pay to edit your character, you can change that too, along a slider for the voice to alter the yaw/pitch. Then minimum 1 month transition. There you go.

    Noneed for lore-breaking surgery scares like in Dragon Age Veilguard, especially in a world where everybody uses magic so powerful that you close wounds in seconds, raise dead people back from their ashes, where corruption change the body and mind, etc.

    If that's the kind of subtelty you're talking about, then yes I'm all for it.
    I just don't want some unimaginative lore-breaking reminders of the IRL world.
    If I had to keep only one song, it would be this one.
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eCF2pson54s
  • OriazaelOriazael Member, Alpha Two
    edited October 29
    Nikbis wrote: »
    Identity representation?

    No.
    Nikbis wrote: »
    If that's the kind of subtelty you're talking about, then yes I'm all for it.
    I just don't want some unimaginative lore-breaking reminders of the IRL world.

    I think op just means that Verra should have lgbtq+ people in NPCs backgrounds. Like in WoW, a normal quest like Mankirks Wife but instead it was Makirks Husband once in a while. Which I think is the normal stuff you were eluding to with the pre church dogma thing. I would kind of expect the existence of several different ethnicities, orientations etc wouldn't be an issue, it's not really a game breaking thing unless bigotry enters the chat. XD
    Nikbis wrote: »
    That's the kind of Character editor I'd like to see. Diversity in body proportions.

    Heck yes, the sliders in cc weren't available for body yet but it would be awesome if it expands to these lengths. I loved the wrinkles slider too. I hope we get other options like albino and freckle options.
  • NoaaniNoaani Member, Intrepid Pack, Alpha Two
    Sevariel wrote: »
    Identity Representation
    As always, doesn’t need to be loud or even central. It can be as simple as acknowledging that LGBTQ+ people also exist within Verra, in the same understated way that love and companionship are acknowledged in many fantasy realms, just as in real life. No one’s ancestry, identity or loved ones should be viewed as a statement or a form of virtue signaling. Rather, I see it as an opportunity for Intrepid to walk the walk on inclusivity by allowing players from all walks of life to feel truly seen and a part of in this world we’re all so excited about.
    Read the first line of this wiki page, and tell me if anything else is needed - or even should be included - in regards to this.

  • SevarielSevariel Member, Alpha Two
    Nikbis wrote: »
    Identity representation?

    No.

    Christian church and its influence & way of thinking -that anything and everything is a sin- over the centuries is what ultimately led to the need for an LGBT community to form & express a unified voice to correct wrong doings.
    Before that, anyone could be gay, lesbian or whatever whitout repercussion.
    Even trans to some extent. They obviously didn't have the technology we now have yet they had ways. Could raise some eyebrows at the time I assume but nothing more.

    If no church or dogma used that kind of repression back there in Sanctus or in Verra, then there's no need for any of more "inclusivity" or "representation", nor do you need to "feel truly seen" or "welcomed" more than anybody else (you really tried to check the buzz-words don't you?). People can already feel and express themselves without constraint.

    Considering all that's happening with DEI stuff currently in videogaming, you'd only antagonize people by pushing this kind of things out of nowhere and geopardise the future of AoC, rightfully so.

    I appreciate the historical context. It’s clear that, in an ideal world, everyone would be able to express themselves without fear or constraint. Unfortunately, as you pointed out, centuries of repression shaped much of our modern world, especially for LGBTQ+ people. Speaking from personal experience and the stories shared by others who grew up in environments shaped by puritanical influences—especially in places like America’s Bible Belt—I can attest to the value of community, safe spaces, and visibility.

    I agree that true inclusivity means reaching a place where people can feel seen without it being political or divisive. However, I don’t think we can get back to that neutral, accepting place by ignoring representation or pretending it isn’t relevant to many players today. Studies have shown that lack of visibility and support often leads to serious mental health struggles, especially for young people. So while I respect that you may not personally find these themes impactful, many players do, and creating a world where all feel welcome doesn’t need to diminish anyone else’s experience.

    Ultimately, acknowledging the existence of LGBTQ+ characters or relationships within Verra isn’t about pushing an agenda; it’s about creating a world where everyone can feel at home—much like the ideal you described before repression took root. We don't all have that outside of spaces like Verra and to imply that they don't deserve the same break from political realities you claim to crave, is not in alignment with the vision of growing a successful and long term fanbase that we do all need for Verra (and Earth) to truly thrive someday.

    I appreciate the chance to have this discussion with you and respect that we’re all coming from different backgrounds and viewpoints. :smile:

  • SevarielSevariel Member, Alpha Two
    edited October 29
    Noaani wrote: »
    Read the first line of this wiki page, and tell me if anything else is needed - or even should be included - in regards to this.

    Hi ^^

    I appreciate you bringing up the wiki entry! I actually mentioned the confirmation of same-sex marriages in an earlier comment, which I think is a great step forward. Steven being Steven and then that confirmation in 2017 was actually one of the reason's I started tuning in back then. However, as Oriazael highlighted, what I’m suggesting is more about subtle background diversity—like the occasional quest mentioning an LGBTQ+ character, similar to the example of "Mankrik’s Wife" in WoW, where, once in a while, it might be "Mankrik’s Husband" instead.

    These kinds of details are generally unobtrusive and wouldn’t affect gameplay for anyone who prefers not to focus on them. They’re the kind of minor lore touches that add depth and richness for those who notice and appreciate them. This is really what I meant when I said, ‘subtle gestures toward inclusivity—however small—could make Verra feel like a more welcoming place for everyone who wants to call it home.’

    I’m genuinely open to everyone’s ideas and input here and don’t mean to shut anyone down; I think this more important by the minute. At the same time, many of the counterarguments posted so far seem to work against themselves. If the presence of diversity is subtle and non-intrusive, there’s little reason it should negatively impact anyone’s experience.

    - Small nods in the lore—like a character mentioning their spouse in passing—without making it a central or highlighted part of any storyline. This allows representation in a way that’s organic and optional for those paying close attention to dialogue or backstory.

    - Occasionally weaving LGBTQ+ representation into background lore—such as an NPC briefly mentioning their same-gender partner or the loss of a loved one—would subtly enrich Verra’s world. It’s not the focus of any major storyline, but rather a natural part of the fabric of everyday life for those who choose to pay attention.

    Much like diversity in real life, these small details make the world feel genuine and inclusive without overtly drawing attention or disrupting the core fantasy.

    Diverse Character Customization Options: This would include appearance sliders to flatten a chest, shorten arms or traits (like freckles, albino options, etc.) that reflect different backgrounds and types. It enriches character creation and gives everyone a way to feel more connected to their characters without affecting the main story or gameplay for others. (Intrepid has been very clear that we haven't seen the whole tip of the iceberg with CC yet so I'm confident it's going to be diverse and robust in time)

    These additions wouldn’t detract from anyone’s experience, but they would help make Verra feel more like a place where everyone belongs.
  • GarrtokGarrtok Member, Alpha Two
    So the NPCS talk maximum five sentences. Why should they talk about their sexuality? Maybe everyone in the world of ashes is gay and that would be okay, the thing is, why should they mention it. Just because there should be a token?
  • BlackBronyBlackBrony Member, Alpha Two
    Garrtok wrote: »
    So the NPCS talk maximum five sentences. Why should they talk about their sexuality? Maybe everyone in the world of ashes is gay and that would be okay, the thing is, why should they mention it. Just because there should be a token?

    Why should they mention they're straight then? Or why mention they have children, that's implying they're straight as well.
    These things are needed because they exist.
    It's not some hidden agenda, or trying to do anything, it's just something that exists and should be acknowledged.
  • GarrtokGarrtok Member, Alpha Two
    BlackBrony wrote: »
    Garrtok wrote: »
    So the NPCS talk maximum five sentences. Why should they talk about their sexuality? Maybe everyone in the world of ashes is gay and that would be okay, the thing is, why should they mention it. Just because there should be a token?

    Why should they mention they're straight then? Or why mention they have children, that's implying they're straight as well.
    These things are needed because they exist.
    It's not some hidden agenda, or trying to do anything, it's just something that exists and should be acknowledged.

    That's the thing. They don't. There is no npc stating that he's so straight
  • I’d prefer if they focused upon pvp, and game mechanics. There are tons of mmo’s that cater to the larping community, and very few that cater to the pvp community. I take no issue with flavor, as long as it doesn’t stifle progress in aforementioned areas of the game.
  • DepravedDepraved Member, Alpha Two
    im against inclusivity for the sake of inclusivity. if its something that fits the story,t hen sure. the actors adapt to the characters, and the characters adapt to the play. the play doesn't adapt to the actors.

    if we gonna include groups for the sake of including groups, then we need to include ALL groups and every possible way you can subdivide humans, otherwise, someone will be left out and complain. why acknowledge one group only then? why is one specific group more important than everyone else?
  • LodrigLodrig Member
    edited October 29
    Haters are so pathetic, pretending that Gays and Lesbians are 'modern' and didn't exist in past ages like for example anchient GREECE AND ROME, which btw folks are OLDER then the Medival periods which are the inspiration for Tolkeinesque fantasy. I remember when folks said the same BS about having a black character in LoL.

    The games lore is currently very bare bones and needs a lot of expanding, and when it is that will include sexual orientation diversity, for it not too would make it both unrealistic and needlessly exclusionary. Intrepid has been clear that they are not going to fufill the fantasies of the haters who want LGBT people to NOT exist.
  • GaettuskGaettusk Member, Alpha Two
    a0n62ili0ziw.png
  • DolyemDolyem Member, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    As others have said, give me all sorts of in-game lore and backgrounds of the races and cultures of Verra. Get super detailed and creative. Explain the differences in Tulnar. Show me why the Kaelar is a nation with so many different people. Tell me why the dunir and the nikua are so distinct as opposed to other races.

    Just don't go pushing a real world agenda into it like certain DEI consultant agencies who have been repeatedly failing within the gaming industry and even destroying established franchises stories.
    GJjUGHx.gif
  • SevarielSevariel Member, Alpha Two
    Garrtok wrote: »
    So the NPCS talk maximum five sentences. Why should they talk about their sexuality? Maybe everyone in the world of ashes is gay and that would be okay, the thing is, why should they mention it. Just because there should be a token?

    Great question, Garrtok. I’d say it’s not so much about explicitly mentioning sexuality as it is about making Verra feel like a vibrant, lived-in world. Though NPCs might not announce 'I'm straight' or 'I'm gay,' the way relationships and families are referenced—like a character mentioning their spouse or a lost love—does add to the richness of the world. Including subtle nods to all kinds of relationships doesn’t make one group more visible or important; it just reflects the variety of human experiences. In fantasy worlds, these small details enrich the story and often go unnoticed by those who aren’t looking for them. It’s not about ‘tokenism’ but about adding depth to the world in a way that makes it feel relatable without impacting anyone’s gameplay experience. After all, if these subtle inclusions make Verra more meaningful to some players, I think we can ALL win here. Personal note, my husband has two biological children that we raise together. Family culture is also diverse.
    Slipree wrote: »
    I’d prefer if they focused upon pvp, and game mechanics. There are tons of mmo’s that cater to the larping community, and very few that cater to the pvp community. I take no issue with flavor, as long as it doesn’t stifle progress in aforementioned areas of the game.

    Totally get where you’re coming from, Slipree. PvP and core gameplay mechanics are absolutely essential to Ashes of Creation and are, in a way, the bones of the game. I’m here primarily for the PvP experience and the camaraderie, but like a lot of others, I enjoy a blend of roleplay as well. That’s why I’m so thrilled that Ashes is PVX—balancing PvP and PvE in a way that lets everyone find their place. Intrepid is building out a ton of creative systems that go beyond PvP: tavern games, player shops, animal husbandry—there’s something for any type of player to fall in love with.

    I personally feel it’s these small, immersive details that give those solid mechanics a bit of soul. A hint of flavor in NPC backgrounds doesn’t detract from core gameplay or PvP focus but rather helps make Verra feel more alive. A bit of flavor here and there doesn’t hold back progress; it just adds layers to the immersion that some players genuinely appreciate.
    Depraved wrote: »
    im against inclusivity for the sake of inclusivity. if its something that fits the story,t hen sure. the actors adapt to the characters, and the characters adapt to the play. the play doesn't adapt to the actors.

    if we gonna include groups for the sake of including groups, then we need to include ALL groups and every possible way you can subdivide humans, otherwise, someone will be left out and complain. why acknowledge one group only then? why is one specific group more important than everyone else?

    Thanks for sharing, Depraved. I think the key isn’t about ‘inclusivity for the sake of inclusivity’ but about honoring the variety of human experiences in subtle ways that can fit naturally into Verra. It’s not about *higlighting* any one group; it’s about creating a world that feels as complex and varied as our own. Small touches like an NPC casually mentioning a partner, regardless of gender, can help some players feel more at home without drawing attention to any one group. These details simply mirror life and don’t demand focus from anyone who isn’t interested in them.
    Lodrig wrote: »
    Haters are so pathetic, pretending that Gays and Lesbians are 'modern' and didn't exist in past ages like for example anchient GREECE AND ROME, which btw folks are OLDER then the Medival periods which are the inspiration for Tolkeinesque fantasy. I remember when folks said the same BS about having a black character in LoL.

    The games lore is currently very bare bones and needs a lot of expanding, and when it is that will include sexual orientation diversity, for it not too would make it both unrealistic and needlessly exclusionary. Intrepid has been clear that they are not going to fufill the fantasies of the haters who want LGBT people to NOT exist.

    Heard, Lodrig! History itself shows that diverse relationships and backgrounds are anything but ‘modern’ concepts—many ancient cultures openly accepted a range of orientations and identities. Just as Ashes draws inspiration from medieval and classical themes, it makes sense to include the same human variety we’d see in those historical settings. As you mentioned, the lore is still developing, and when it does, subtle inclusivity will only make it richer. A diverse world is, in many ways, a more believable and engaging one, and Ashes is certainly aiming to craft a world that feels full and real.
    Gaettusk wrote: »
    a0n62ili0ziw.png

    Appreciate the insight here, Gaettusk. Steven’s point is well taken—no one’s here to politicize Ashes of Creation or make it a platform for real-world debates. That said, I think it’s worth remembering that diversity in storytelling isn’t about politics or forcing modern culture into the game. It’s simply about making Verra feel like a rich, nuanced place, with subtle nods to different human experiences that reflect the variety we’d see in any living, breathing world.

    Verra was born from the mind of someone who has openly expressed an open heart and mind where this topic is concerned, and I trust that means it’ll be a space that feels welcoming to all kinds of players, as long as they're down for the core systems. Intrepid’s inclusion of same-sex marriage back in 2017 tells me this isn’t something fringe—it’s simply already a part of Verra’s landscape.

    As I mentioned earlier, I’m really here for a think tank, not to create division. So, I’d love to shift gears back to the creative brainstorming. How might we bring Verra’s many cultures to life through game mechanics or world lore? Maybe it’s something like diverse NPC festivals, regional quests inspired by different in-lore cultures, or player-driven events that celebrate Verra’s diversity.

    Let’s get back to that kind of exploration—it’s way more fun and inspiring!
  • SevarielSevariel Member, Alpha Two
    edited October 29
    What if when Tulnar eat something from the under dark they have a higher regen rate or slight boost compared to a Dwarf eating the same thing and maybe a visual wooziness comes over them from time to time or they occasionally puke in battle.

    I wonder if Dunir will be better rock climbers or miners.. Can't wait to see the racial perks when they reveal them.

    Deep within the ancient forests of the Py'rai, an ethereal breeze carries whispers of riddles tied to mystical hotspots. Py'rai players, attuned to the forest’s magic, experience unique clues that resonate with ancestral knowledge, guiding them more easily to the hotspots where magical resources bloom. Here, they uncover lore fragments about the Py'rai’s ancient bonds with the land and nature spirits, granting insight into the deeper mysteries of their race.

    For other races, deciphering the breeze’s riddles is more challenging, requiring a Py'rai partnership or old fashioned keen observation and puzzle-solving skills. Players must decide whether to form alliances or risk conflict, as control over these hotspots grants harvestable resources, rare herbs, and buffs tailored for PvP. Lore-based incentives include things like fragments of knowledge that, when pieced together, hint at hidden locations in other regions of Verra, creating a broader, interconnected lore-seeking experience.

    OR

    In the secluded Niküa Isles, the Tidecaller’s Shrine rises from the sea during specific seasonal windows. Niküa players, whose ancestral ties link them deeply to the ocean, gain unique access to the shrine’s historical context, learning about rituals that honor the ocean’s spirits. As they participate in agility, puzzle-solving, and combat trials, they uncover lore fragments about ancient maritime routes and seafaring lore, unlocking special quests exclusive to Niküa culture.

    Other players face tougher trials and must form temporary alliances or battle it out for control of the shrine. The Tidecaller’s Rite rewards victors with temporary seafaring advantages like faster travel speeds, PvP bonuses on water, and rare crafting items that enhance shipbuilding. Additionally, non-Niküa players can uncover lore clues that lead to hidden islands or undersea treasure maps, making the event enticing for all races, with layers of narrative that deepen the world’s sense of discovery.
  • susp1cioussusp1cious Member, Alpha Two
    edited October 29
    The funny thing is that your own thoughts about this don't make any sense. You can't make everybody feel at home - we're humans. What some find comforting, others find disturbing or unnatural.
    I don't give a damn about the sexuality of fictional characters, but the moment somebody is explicitly mentioning to me their sexuality in a "natural" way, obviously the person has some issues. Otherwise you wouldn't use that as defining trait.

    In real life, nobody is telling you their sexuality in some kind of random conversation. Trying to force it into video game dialogue is extremely off-putting to me.
    (Uninformed opinions on how sexuality was handled in Greece even more so - homosexuality in itself wasn't celebrated at all. It was more in line with the grooming of minors in celebration of the aesthetics of the body, so when somebody started mentioning this I can't help myself but laugh.)

    Maybe I'm overinterpreting what you're saying, but you've gone full out on the prose here so I can't stop myself from feeling that what you're trying to achieve here is sophism at its finest. Even though there are some valid points your making, this feels more like the push for an agenda where the one profiting is foremost you and people like you - that are the minority - who feel that forced representation and signaling is the only way for you to feel at home "properly".

    Because we both know that the majority certainly won't. Nobody cares.
    But the moment you start putting sexuality on the table, people will care - which will make this incredibly toxic for everyone involved.
    Just let it be.

    PS: The thing is, I wasn't even thinking once about the sexuality of the NPCs before you mentioned it - they can have sex with a tree for all I care - but you talking about it when at this point it doesn't even feel as if NPC's will really matter, makes me very doubtful of your intentions.


  • SevarielSevariel Member, Alpha Two
    edited October 29
    susp1cious wrote: »
    The funny thing is that your own thoughts about this don't make any sense. You can't make everybody feel at home - we're humans. What some find comforting, others find disturbing or unnatural.
    I don't give a damn about the sexuality of fictional characters, but the moment somebody is explicitly mentioning to me their sexuality in a "natural" way, obviously the person has some issues. Otherwise you wouldn't use that as defining trait.

    In real life, nobody is telling you their sexuality in some kind of random conversation. Trying to force it into video game dialogue is extremely off-putting to me.
    (Uninformed opinions on how sexuality was handled in Greece even more so - homosexuality in itself wasn't celebrated at all. It was more in line with the grooming of minors in celebration of the aesthetics of the body, so when somebody started mentioning this I can't help myself but laugh.)

    Maybe I'm overinterpreting what you're saying, but you've gone full out on the prose here so I can't stop myself from feeling that what you're trying to achieve here is sophism at its finest. Even though there are some valid points your making, this feels more like the push for an agenda where the one profiting is foremost you and people like you - which are the minority - who feel that forced representation and signaling is the only way for you to feel at home "properly".

    Because we both know that the majority certainly won't. Nobody cares.
    But the moment you start putting sexuality on the table, people will care - which will make this incredibly toxic for everyone involved.
    Just let it be.

    PS: The thing is, I wasn't even thinking once about the sexuality of the NPCs before you mentioned it - they can have sex with a tree for all I care - but you talking about it when at this point it doesn't even feel as if NPC's will really matter, makes me very doubtful of your intentions.


    The other day on a plane, someone asked if I was flying with anyone, and I casually replied, ‘Yeah! My husband is sitting over there.’ It wasn’t overt, uncomfortable, or suggestive in any way—it was just a straightforward mention of my partner. If hearing that feels ‘too much’ or seems loaded, that’s really a reflection of the listener, not the speaker.

    For a good example of how simple, everyday acknowledgments of someone’s romantic life can be woven into conversation without being ‘in-your-face,’ take a look at the first 1:10 of this Ashes of Creation livestream from December 2021 before the UE5 announcement: https://youtu.be/HB7gWTpeB08?feature=shared&t=41 It’s a great example of how natural and non-intrusive these mentions can be.

    It’s true—there’s no single way to make everyone feel at home in a game as diverse as Ashes of Creation. People are unique, and what resonates with one player might not even register with another. That’s exactly why I’m excited about a world like Verra, where subtle layers of different experiences can coexist, creating a more vibrant and realistic environment without needing to be overt.

    To clarify, it’s not about having characters ‘explicitly mention’ their sexuality. Rather, it’s the idea of crafting a world where small details reflect a variety of backgrounds, be it an offhand mention of a spouse, a family tradition, or a cultural reference. Think of it as background color rather than front-and-center staging—these are things that just happen to be part of the world, adding depth for those who notice, without needing to define anyone’s experience.

    In the end, it’s about crafting an immersive world where subtle diversity just…exists, much like it does in our own.

    Honestly, I’m more than willing to drop this topic if it causes discomfort—like I said, it was just one idea among many. That said, it’s interesting to see how certain viewpoints tend to bubble up even here in the Ashes of Creation community. When more lore and world details are revealed down the line, I imagine there will be plenty of spirited discussions around these themes.

    If you genuinely believe my points on these topics aren’t making sense and would like to try to understand, feel free to DM me with the specific points that seem unclear. I’d be happy to walk you through.

    I don’t see this as a political issue at all, but I get that sometimes framing something as ‘political’ can be a way of pushing back against aspects of personal freedom that don’t align with one’s own preferences.

    Ultimately, I’m here for the game, the lore, and the rich world that Intrepid is building for all of us to enjoy, quirks and all. So, here’s to more engaging conversations in the future, wherever the story takes us. :smile:
  • edited October 30
    To be frank this looks like a wall of text to ask for a LGBT recognition "feature". Why all this smoke screen about caring about representation of made up races and made up cultures?

    How does the OP suggest that we allow players to express LGBT identity or their character? Why should that matter? Yes, you exist my dude. No, most people couldn't care less about your sexual orientation and with who you are having a consensual relationship and why.

    Highlighting sexual identity (whatever that identity would be) has very little to add to a MMORPG setting. Whatever backstory of your character you make, why exactly should that little detail matter and get any exposure?

    A while back I asked for a text field to be added to the character sheet. Something players could fill in, if they like the idea of some light role play / character backstory. Something you could inspect on any character you meet / befriend.

    Maybe if this ever gets added, then you could put whatever short fantasy story you come up with about your character.

  • SevarielSevariel Member, Alpha Two
    edited October 30
    To be frank this looks like a wall of text to ask for LGBT recognition "feature". Why all this smoke screen about caring about representation of made up races and made up cultures?

    How does the OP suggest that we allow players to "express LGBT identity or their character? Why does it matter? Yes you exist my dude. No I couldn't care less about your sexual orientation and with who you are having a consensual relationship and why.

    Highlighting sexual identity (whatever that identity would be) has very little to add to a MMORPG. Whatever backstory of your character you make, why exactly should that little detail matter and get any exposure?

    Uh, ya got me. You definitely read, understood and I've been made. I raised this topic to request a rainbow face paint and achievable "gay" title. :D

    While I am super curious to know what you're imagining these features would entail.. No one is here looking for LGBT ‘features'; besides same-sex marriage, thanks again, Steven. It’s more about crafting Verra as a world with depth and small, ambient details that enrich the story for those who look closely.

    It goes without saying, anyone who wants to watch is invited to my wedding when it's implemented. :)
  • DolyemDolyem Member, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    edited October 30
    Sevariel wrote: »
    To be frank this looks like a wall of text to ask for LGBT recognition "feature". Why all this smoke screen about caring about representation of made up races and made up cultures?

    How does the OP suggest that we allow players to "express LGBT identity or their character? Why does it matter? Yes you exist my dude. No I couldn't care less about your sexual orientation and with who you are having a consensual relationship and why.

    Highlighting sexual identity (whatever that identity would be) has very little to add to a MMORPG. Whatever backstory of your character you make, why exactly should that little detail matter and get any exposure?

    Uh, ya got me. You definitely read, understood and I've been made. I raised this topic to request a rainbow face paint and achievable "gay" title. :D

    While I am super curious to know what you're imagining these features would entail.. No one is here looking for LGBT ‘features'; besides same-sex marriage, thanks again, Steven. It’s more about crafting Verra as a world with depth and small, ambient details that enrich the story for those who look closely.

    It goes without saying, anyone who wants to watch is invited to my wedding when it's implemented. :)

    There was a conversation somewhat similar to this before on here. Honestly when it comes down to people being overly cautious about all of the "diversity, equity, and inclusion" words getting tossed around, it is pretty justified to be suspicious of these things in regards to how they have been effecting games lately.

    BUT. That being said. It doesnt mean that you cant have those things if you have good writing, continuity, and the heart is in the place of building an amazing fantasy world as opposed to making sure the world represents a bunch of things and people.

    One example. I totally want lots of backstory on tulnar and why there are apes, reptiles, and other sorts of mammals, and how it makes sense with their compatibilities, cultures, and upbringings. Are there cultural tensions between them due to their differences? What were the races they are derived from. What did their environment do to influence their evolution?

    I also want to know how the Kaelar started off, and how they became "diverse" having what would seem to be humans distinctly differing physically. What were the different nations/parts of the world that the Kaelar allied with, traded with, or conquered to have so much "diversity".
    Why werent the Vaelune included?

    The dwarf races could very well both be solitary races. Explaining their lack of diversity so far. Mountain dwarves could be holed up in their mountain fortresses to themselves. Nikua could rarely ever remain on land, and be a mostly seafaring people. So both of these would have less interactions with eachother or other races.

    This is the sort of diversity I would want to see and be detailed within the game because it builds the world out, and explains why the beings of Verra are the way they are.


    also
    DwuE9TI.gif
    GJjUGHx.gif
  • SevarielSevariel Member, Alpha Two
    Yes, exactly! Good storytelling is the heart of any great fantasy, and Ashes of Creation has the potential to bring Verra’s races to life with rich, layered histories.

    The Vaelune, for example: their rumored connection with the djinn opens up a world of questions. Are they granted similar powers by these supernatural beings, or does each Vaelune individual express unique abilities? Does this attunement often result in quirks in personality or even hidden rivalries between those more closely tied to certain elemental spirits?

    Imagining these possibilities is so exciting while we wait for the servers to come back up. It’d be fascinating to discover through treasure, quests or hints in their architecture just how deeply this bond with the djinn shapes Vaelune culture. Are they protectors, manipulators, or perhaps even students of these spirits?

    This kind of layered storytelling builds Verra into a place where every player has something meaningful to discover.
  • How does the OP suggest that we allow players to express LGBT identity or their character? Why should that matter? Yes, you exist my dude. No, most people couldn't care less about your sexual orientation and with who you are having a consensual relationship and why.

    Highlighting sexual identity (whatever that identity would be) has very little to add to a MMORPG setting. Whatever backstory of your character you make, why exactly should that little detail matter and get any exposure?

    This comment is completely true.

    @Sevariel

    Hi, first of all I want you to understand why people won't accept what you think is a small request of adding some LGTB+ sprinkled over the game.

    As he said, we know you exist, lgtb people have always existed, 99.99% of the population knows it. Then what you are seeking is not representation; is resurance.
    And you only want more reasurance about something that should be normal, everybody understand that it is normal and eveytime you see a reminder of "Gay people exist!, and remember! don't be a bad person!" It's an insult to your intelligence and it implies you being a "suspicious bad person" from the start.

    Now if you think a lgtb love story quest will get some people to finally feel accepted, that's something I will never understand.

    You've been respectful on this post and I appreciate it, these are my thoughts and I'm trying to understand yours too.
  • boredmuseboredmuse Member, Braver of Worlds, Alpha One, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    edited October 30
    Can we just have a game? None of this modern stuff to ruin immersion? I don't care about the sexual preferences of anybody in a GAME.

    Why the need to feel represented in
    a game? There are fictional races, they don't represent anybody....

    Somebody has to make this thread in every MMO forum. Grats, you were the guy here.
  • NoaaniNoaani Member, Intrepid Pack, Alpha Two
    Sevariel wrote: »
    Noaani wrote: »
    Read the first line of this wiki page, and tell me if anything else is needed - or even should be included - in regards to this.

    Hi ^^

    I appreciate you bringing up the wiki entry! I actually mentioned the confirmation of same-sex marriages in an earlier comment, which I think is a great step forward. Steven being Steven and then that confirmation in 2017 was actually one of the reason's I started tuning in back then. However, as Oriazael highlighted, what I’m suggesting is more about subtle background diversity—like the occasional quest mentioning an LGBTQ+ character, similar to the example of "Mankrik’s Wife" in WoW, where, once in a while, it might be "Mankrik’s Husband" instead.
    The world's history would suggest that we will encounter very few married NPC's.

    I would personally view coming across *any* married NPC's in Verra to be somewhat suspicious, at least for a while after launch.

    That is why I consider player marriage to be as much as anyone should expect.
  • It's just horrible
    PvE means: A handful of coins and a bag of boredom.
This discussion has been closed.