When I craft an item, will my name be on it, forever?
Crivel
Member, Founder, Kickstarter
Hi guys!
I loved the Ashes of Creation Meet the Devs & Year-in-Review, and if anyone reading this managed to miss that, you can find it here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DF1d1pb6cME.
One question that came to mind listening to Hal, Alex and Kory during Gathering&Crafting, was that if I craft an item, will my name be in the desription of that item forever?
Like "Sword of ember. crafted by Crivel the journeyman blacksmith" or something like that.
You can even add what rank I have in that profession when I crafted it, so when somone comes to me and want me to craft a similar to him/her, I can reply that "oh, but I am a Master in my craft now so this sword will be a much better piece"
The reason I ask, is that as far as i understand it will be somewhat harder to gather the right materials, and when you actually craft the item there will be some type of minigame where you can determine the final result of the items properties?
Add that your choice of religion and path of life in Ashes in general can affect what properties your crafted item will end up with, can make it quite uniqe.
And it would be grand if my name would be on that item then, so people can learn who crafted it, and come and find me to get one of their own.
A way to build up your reputation as a crafter?
"I heard there is a Master Blacksmith somewhere in the Jundark region who can craft weapons with the most amazing looks and abillities.
I dont know if you can inspect other players in Ashes, but I suspect you will be able to.
But then you can look at their gear, and read the description and see the name of the crafter of that bow, sword or armor, or who tamed his or her´s mount and so on.
Just a thought, perhaps its already answered somewhere, but I wanted to ask anyway
Thanks guys for reading.
I loved the Ashes of Creation Meet the Devs & Year-in-Review, and if anyone reading this managed to miss that, you can find it here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DF1d1pb6cME.One question that came to mind listening to Hal, Alex and Kory during Gathering&Crafting, was that if I craft an item, will my name be in the desription of that item forever?
Like "Sword of ember. crafted by Crivel the journeyman blacksmith" or something like that.
You can even add what rank I have in that profession when I crafted it, so when somone comes to me and want me to craft a similar to him/her, I can reply that "oh, but I am a Master in my craft now so this sword will be a much better piece"
The reason I ask, is that as far as i understand it will be somewhat harder to gather the right materials, and when you actually craft the item there will be some type of minigame where you can determine the final result of the items properties?
Add that your choice of religion and path of life in Ashes in general can affect what properties your crafted item will end up with, can make it quite uniqe.
And it would be grand if my name would be on that item then, so people can learn who crafted it, and come and find me to get one of their own.
A way to build up your reputation as a crafter?
"I heard there is a Master Blacksmith somewhere in the Jundark region who can craft weapons with the most amazing looks and abillities.
I dont know if you can inspect other players in Ashes, but I suspect you will be able to.
But then you can look at their gear, and read the description and see the name of the crafter of that bow, sword or armor, or who tamed his or her´s mount and so on.
Just a thought, perhaps its already answered somewhere, but I wanted to ask anyway
Thanks guys for reading.
0
Comments
Games have been doing this for almost 20 years (that I know of), so it isn't some great new idea.
The developers believe that inspecting gear to obtain an exact equipment list or gear score may lead to "unwelcome behavior".[8]
An item may be inspectable but simply not show exact details.
Inspect should open a pop-up (if you allow it) that asks for permission, and only if you accept other people should be able to see the names of your gear pieces and all the details.
Similar to Ultima Online GM system
A GrandMaster Blacksmith will finally have his GM made items show his name as the creator.
This should be a achievement, a reward for a hard work to master in AoC.
In terms of Inspection - I'm all for it.
Just let me know if someone is inspecting me is all.
So why not have their guild rating by their name?
A Journeyman still creates at his current best.
Always allow inspect.
Never allow inspect.
Ask to inspect.
Inspect should be a part of the game as well I think.
Definitely want inspect and I wouldn’t mind always allow it’s worked in other games it leads to motivation and awe from other players who like to view gear and want to hunt for their next set. I always loved looking at high level characters and there gear it’s a lot of fun seeing what you could possibly get if you keep grinding.
I would settle for:
Always allow inspect.
Never allow inspect.
Ask to inspect.
I’m all for names on gear to. Possibly something you can obtain mid way through your progression in that profession. Not noob and not master somewhere in between.
That's fair. If someone has to have at least put some form of dedication into their craft in order to have their name displayed on it, I wouldn't mind. I'd just Luke the inspect options to prevent someone knowing too much about their target.
Example: I'm a rogue. I need the rock you are mining. Rock u r mining is master level. I can't mine rock since I am chose a different set of professions. I inspect you. I conclude I can't most likely kill you for it becuz of gear u r wearing. Or I conclude I can't so I wait for next person.
I don't believe a player should have so much info about another if they aren't on friendly terms. If your gonna make the choice to turn red for a chance at loot then you should do so without knowing such info about your enemy. How do you feel about this line of thought?
You’re probably going to have a good idea of there power from just looking at their armour anyway. I doubt this information you get from them will make much difference. Personally I wouldn’t mind anyone from knowing my gear I’m used to it from other games. You won’t know there skill and that’s what matters. I accept the compromise though.
That's fair, though with transmog you wouldn't be able to tell unless transmog visibility has a toggle. I could go either way, just thinking of ways it may cause friction or give someone an unnecessary benefit
Earn it. Risk/Reward.
Risk - the time length it took for you to become a grandmaster.
Reward - the server recognizes your accomplishment.
more specifically - not every item/gear gets tagged with names. Legendary items, or legendary mats that can only be crafted by Grandmaster can etch their names. So there is only a select few dedicated crafters of that caliber in the server.
Ashes isnt giving out participation trophies - their principles / pillar is aligned to this concept. Reputation matters and this is one avenue of it.
Items levels probably isnt for this game and this might be along EQ / D&D itemization route. With that said - inspection is fine.
I think its a cop out, inspecting someone and going - ohh noes, I cant fight him.
that is shitty design and gameplay. "I wont fight cause he's too geared, to better." or "lulz, look at this lvl 60 newbie with shit gear, i can kill him easily" - both scenerio is lame.
I do believe, Since steven is a D&D / Pathfinder type of guy - that items are nominal increases to a player growth.
So like EQ - a naked wizard vs a geared wizard - the difference would be
the geared wizard would have a large mana pool, hp pool, AC, mana regen and maybe an increase 25-33% magical dmg increase.
So a naked wizard fireball would be 1000, the geared one is 1250-1333 dmg.
Whereas NW/WoW itemzation is stupid and makes things hard to balance
a naked wizard fireball is 1000 vs a geared wizard is 18,384 dmg.
Most people arent inspecting to see gankability but to awe/admire the item. Like holy shit, that is an awesome looking robe, let me click and see the name of the robe. Is this a mage robe? cleric robe? Int robe? wis robe? vit robe?
Its much better design to be able to say "I cant fight him" just by looking at their class, as Ashes essentially plans to do.
A game with RPS classes makes it more obvious who you are able to kill and who you are unable to kill than a game where gear is the major determining factor.
I have read all your comments, and I share your concerns regarding granting to much information to a would-be opponent.
My initial concern was, as some of you have been mentioning as well, is the reputation.
As far as I have understand it, there will be plenty of different approaches to how to improve your crafting.
You can become a armorblacksmith that follows a certin type of religion and thus be able to add special buffs to the armor you create.
Or weaponsmith, or tailoring, jewelcrafting and so on.
From my own perspective, I want my craft to be known, I want everyone to be able to look at a player who is using my crafted items and see my name on it, so they can get the chance to seek me out to get the same "unique" buff as well.
Otherwise it will be very hard for me as a crafter to be known, to be valued.
If I devote my time to become a grandmaster armorsmith while also becomming a high ranked member of a religios group, or whatever social thing that grant me the possibillities to enhance my crafting with buffs, I want my reputation to grow.
I want people to know that if they want a ring with fire protection, I, Crivel the gemmologist is the one to seek out.
From another player´s perspective, as a few others also wrote above, I want to look at a player and see what type of gear they have, to get some hints of how to improve my own gear.
So perhaps a limited amount of information can be provided at all times, like buffs and name of crafter?
But specifik stats wont be mentioned to avoid showing exactly how strong the character might be?
if I have the skills to craft items like the ring I mentioned earlier, or the "Fire sword of swiftness", where Grandmaster Crivel added x amount % of attackspeed to the weapon, from his skills in blacksmithing, and firedamage from his devoution to the heretic priests of Guál dan, the firelord. (pure fiction, but you get the point
I want it to be known, my reputation to be spread.
So if I want fire damage on my weapon, or a jewelry with fire protection, I know I need to find this Crivel, and I as this blacksmith or gemmologist, I would have a chance to get more customers and actually make a living as a crafter.
Imagine a Smith named "Bussy". Like that tiny, adorable Kid from Witcher II. (lol)
And then the toughest Bulldog-kind of skilled Fighters wield Weapons, forged by "Bussy" ... ... ...
✓ Occasional Roleplayer
✓ Kinda starting to look for a Guild right now. (German)
That way, your mass produced auction trash could not be seen as you are the one spamming the auction with minor swords of ill repute for newbies. Maybe the inscribe feature only applied for rare items and above.
Also there is maybe opportunity for interplay here with actual scribes. To get a scribe scroll that allows a weapon crafter to apply a custom scribed weapon name and crafted by line.