Glorious Alpha Two Testers!

Phase I of Alpha Two testing will occur on weekends. Each weekend is scheduled to start on Fridays at 10 AM PT and end on Sundays at 10 PM PT. Find out more here.

Check out Alpha Two Announcements here to see the latest Alpha Two news and update notes.

Our quickest Alpha Two updates are in Discord. Testers with Alpha Two access can chat in Alpha Two channels by connecting your Discord and Intrepid accounts here.

Should there be brothels in the game?

2

Comments

  • No. I would not like them wasting time on making brothels in game. I will watch some porn if feel the need, or meet someone in real life.
  • Rohkai said:
    What happened? You got a disease....
    They have something similar in AOC (age of conan). There's a lady named Two-Tricks and you either get a small buff or a small debuff.. :D 

    Someone mentioned media repercussions - I think it would  be minimal. There was very little when AOC came out with topless females and barely a passing mention in articles when Conan Exiles came out with full nudity (male and female). It matters how the game is marketed and what the target audience is. They were marketed as adult MMOs.

    To answer the topic: sure, why not? People can partake or not - not like it'll a quest.. or.. will it? ;)
  • Sozia said:
    The dudes at the brothel better be smoking hot. 
    I've got to agree. Make sure to cater to multiple groups, no exclusion.
    On a real note, No there should not be brothels. WTF. I'd try to wrap my mind around the logic of this, but I'd just feel even more pity. 
  • I don't want that kind of experience in the game
  • ArchivedUserArchivedUser Guest
    edited June 2017
    I couldn't care less for them being in game. Don't really see the need.
    It would only serve male ego.  You know, for those that need to build it up due to lack of any other means.   B)
    I can see your viewpoint, but I'd like to counter it, just a little bit.

    I've known, and @Possum has known, players who RP courtesans and the like. Now, that's a bit more difficult than you may think; we think "brothel" and of course everyone instantly lights up with a big, shiny sign that says "S3X!" in their minds. But historically, brothels were multi-faceted, and even today, there are different facets to the "sex" industry -- and no, I'm not talking about those who are suborned into it, either as children or as adults.

    In the case of courtesans, often these were women of vast knowledge and learning, who offered entertainments -- from their accompaniment at events to smaller, more intimate meetings of intellectuals and/or politicians, among others. For reference to a more modernistic view of this, think of Inara, in Firefly.

    So, "should" there be? I don't know that I think it's a thing that IS "should" create, but I don't see why some enterprising role player(s) couldn't do something along those lines.

    There's a vast difference, by the way, between "Role Play" and "Erotic Role Play." ERP is what everyone thinks of, these days, when this topic comes up, but it's actually a great deal broader than that, and can be far more meaningful.
  • Media backlash?

    The first time I logged into Rust, the first person I ran into was stark naked, tea bagging a naked corpse on the ground, both with their man parts on full display, glistening in the sun.

    I don't recall CNN or the BBC caring all that much.
  • Clearly, it would be a very small part of the game.  Perhaps only appearing when a node reaches the Village / City level.  NPC only, no player run brothels.

    Seedy ones in the poor part of town, lavish ones in the rich part.

    No real details or intense graphics of course; no place or need for that.... I was thinking more along the lines of how the old Monte Python movies handled the subject with a little humorous dialog.

  • I usually partake in fantasy worlds to do the sort of activities which are impossible in the real world, so I would consider this a waste of development resources.
  • Tholren said:
    I usually partake in fantasy worlds to do the sort of activities which are impossible in the real world, so I would consider this a waste of development resources.
    You vastly overestimate what I can accomplish in the real world. 
    ;)
  • I'm not sure, but I'm hoping to run an elven maid cafe :)
  • @Isende though I do understand your point on where courtesans doesn't necessarily mean prostitute, but I don't see how it would be a practical use of development time to add in a courtesan system, besides O.P. did say brothel with a clear intended implication of the neon sign that you mentioned.

    All in all it is my opinion that IS should leave the subject alone and let the players decided to make one if they feel the need.

    Firefly was a good show wish it ran longer, was sad when they cut it short and turned it into the movie that they did
  • I'm sure some budding entrepreneur will come up with some player made... Brothel of sorts. 

    Or a religious node dedicated to the god/godless of procreation. Hardworking priest's and priestesses doing God's work. 
  • Ofc, there should be brothels in the game!.
    You also should be available to capture other players that you defeat in PvP, and force them to work in it!!!
  • MADE said:
    Ofc, there should be brothels in the game!.
    You also should be available to capture other players that you defeat in PvP, and force them to work in it!!!
    This in my mind is along the lines of a prison which I strongly recommend not having in game
  • MADE said:
    Ofc, there should be brothels in the game!.
    You also should be available to capture other players that you defeat in PvP, and force them to work in it!!!
    This in my mind is along the lines of a prison which I strongly recommend not having in game
    You know, they could have a cut from the money they earn...
  • MADE said:
    You know, they could have a cut from the money they earn...
    You are such a generous pimp.
  • I can see it now:
    Raid Leader: Alright folks, we're calling the raid early!
    Random Raider: Why?
    Raid Leader: The tanks have chlamydia, two of the healers are down with bad case of genital herpes, and the rest of the raid has a bad case of gonorrhea.



    isn't that why priests usually have cure disease spells?
  • @Isende though I do understand your point on where courtesans doesn't necessarily mean prostitute, but I don't see how it would be a practical use of development time to add in a courtesan system, besides O.P. did say brothel with a clear intended implication of the neon sign that you mentioned.

    All in all it is my opinion that IS should leave the subject alone and let the players decided to make one if they feel the need.

    Firefly was a good show wish it ran longer, was sad when they cut it short and turned it into the movie that they did
    I agree, I think I did mention that that wasn't my goal, to see studio-created brothels, etc. :smile:
  • Isende said:
    @Isende though I do understand your point on where courtesans doesn't necessarily mean prostitute, but I don't see how it would be a practical use of development time to add in a courtesan system, besides O.P. did say brothel with a clear intended implication of the neon sign that you mentioned.

    All in all it is my opinion that IS should leave the subject alone and let the players decided to make one if they feel the need.

    Firefly was a good show wish it ran longer, was sad when they cut it short and turned it into the movie that they did
    I agree, I think I did mention that that wasn't my goal, to see studio-created brothels, etc. :smile:
    Yep.  This, just like player created factions, should be entirely in the hands of the players.  Intrepid should not spend any development time on it.  And since we'll have freeholds, it would be rather difficult to stop someone from creating one.
  • I would imagine you can turn a tavern into whatever you want.
  • ArchivedUserArchivedUser Guest
    edited June 2017
    Who needs the developers to make ingame brothels? Just get a PVXXX guild to make a redlight district in one of the cities.
  • I hope not I want to introduce my son to his first mmo
  • ... Why was this Topic Made again ?
  • Oh I know, I can't start a condom company, selling Snake Skin Condoms, +10 endurance, Use:cast cleanse. 
  • I play to escape real life.   No need to bring the trash of society here as well lol.
  • I hope not I want to introduce my son to his first mmo

    Well you may think that would be good for your kid, but it isn't.
    If you keep hiding it from him, then it's like letting RNG teach your soon.

    You don't know what it means? It means that he will sooner or later learn it from somewhere. And if you don't teach him before it, that source will going to influence your soon growth, which may takes him into the wrong path, or make him into a anti socialized being, and only rarely ends up at the right path.

    The choice is yours. Idc where do you live, but if you don't talk about it with your kid, but instead try to keep him away from things like that, then you can be 99% sure that others will going to tech him before he reaches legal age, and then you can't control it afterwards...
  • If someone could outline what benefits this would bring I'd be all for it.

    Only benefits I can see are:
    - Limiting access to the game to younger audience
    - Immersion, I say that very loosely
    - People with deep dark MMO fantasies will have their erotic desires fulfilled

    The negatives I can see though are:
    - Limiting access to the game to younger audience
    - Negative impression, "Oh hey you play that MMO with brothels?"
    - Game play value will either be incredibly awkward or just cringe, "Rapidly click to ram faster!"
    - Content I believe only a handful of players will make use of and will only look at once or twice
    - If it provides positive buffs/temporary stat boosts, players that decide not to use them are at a disadvantage
    -If the event can be skipped and acquired anyway or can be acquired somewhere else then it's even more pointless



  • How is this even a debate still it's obviously a yes... as for the "men's ego" comments eh. I expect women to have equal representation with their sexy man escorts as well! Judgement goes hand in hand with both parties involved lead by example not exclusion!!!!
  • Yes.
  • :joy:
    :) 
    :| 
    :/ 
    :angry: No.
Sign In or Register to comment.