Glorious Alpha Two Testers!

Phase I of Alpha Two testing will occur on weekends. Each weekend is scheduled to start on Fridays at 10 AM PT and end on Sundays at 10 PM PT. Find out more here.

Check out Alpha Two Announcements here to see the latest Alpha Two news and update notes.

Our quickest Alpha Two updates are in Discord. Testers with Alpha Two access can chat in Alpha Two channels by connecting your Discord and Intrepid accounts here.

Warning from my previous experiences facing healers balanced around PvE.

1234568

Comments

  • P0GG0P0GG0 Member, Alpha Two
    i feel sorry for you. at least you got the better loots, congratz.
  • LudulluLudullu Member, Alpha Two
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    i feel sorry for you. at least you got the better loots, congratz.
    I got the better game and life experience. I woulda been much worse off if I hadn't learned how to socialize with people through playing a game that forced me to party/guild up.

    There's countless single player games to enjoy by yourself, but only a few good mmos that force you to be a part of smth much bigger.
  • NiKr wrote: »
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    Do you realise the amount of people that dont like to take part in this guild thing ? why would you get a ridiculous advantage just for being that extravert gene pool ?
    And literally all of those people can go play a NON-MULTIPLAYER game.

    Also, I've been a shut-in introvert my whole life, but I've also being in guilds as a member and as a leader. You don't have to be an extravert to do that.

    Probably there are degrees of introversion.
    And people thinking they are introverts when they are not or not knowing what really means.
    We interact with eachoter in communities since before we were humans.

    Playing solo in mmos can be more a desire to feel the consequences of your own actions, to have your own progression. And reluctance to follow a leader.
  • NoaaniNoaani Member, Intrepid Pack, Alpha Two
    edited December 2023
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    Noaani wrote: »
    It really shouldn't be an issue at all. Ever.

    If you are forming a pickup group - in part or in full - have a healer.

    If you are grouping with friends, make sure one of your friends is a healer. If none of your friends are healers, be a healer.

    Now, some people may say that they prefer the gameplay of a tank or DPS. To these people my only comment is - if you are spending time in an MMO with your friends, and being a healer instead of another class is going to mean you don't enjoy your time, get better friends.

    how is that remotely fun ? also why do need to have friends to be able to compete ?

    The main avenue to fun in an MMORPG when you are playing with friends, should be those friends.

    If your friends are not the main avenue of fun for you, you have shit friends and ao should find others.

    If you are not playing with friends, just ensure one of the people you bring along is a healer - it isn't hard to do this.
  • LudulluLudullu Member, Alpha Two
    Raven016 wrote: »
    Playing solo in mmos can be more a desire to feel the consequences of your own actions, to have your own progression. And reluctance to follow a leader.
    Then become that leader. That's what I did. I hated playing with other people, so I made my own guild, made people play with themselves, while I could still progress bit by bit.

    My main point is that Ashes should remain a party-based game, because almost every damn other game is soloable these days, so people better not come here saying "let me win solo".

    Obviously Ashes will have some solo content. And that solo content might even allow you to fully progress your character, just at a waaay slower pace. But majority of content should require a proper group, rather than a collection of solo randos w/ no trinity and/or coordination. We don't have enough games that have that kind of design, so no fucking wonder that everyone says "mmos are so lonely these days".
  • P0GG0P0GG0 Member, Alpha Two
    Look at the numbers open world survival looter shooters do. and those are mostly solo / duo players.
    diablo 4 implemented that mmo feel to a mostly sologrind franchise and its probably the one thing none complained about.
    why cant we reach that type of player ?

    Devs keep pandering to the zerglings and i'm tired of it.
  • NoaaniNoaani Member, Intrepid Pack, Alpha Two
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    Look at the numbers open world survival looter shooters do. and those are mostly solo / duo players.
    diablo 4 implemented that mmo feel to a mostly sologrind franchise and its probably the one thing none complained about.
    why cant we reach that type of player ?

    Devs keep pandering to the zerglings and i'm tired of it.

    Because Ashes is aiming to be an actual MMORPG, as opposed to a game that sometimes has that feel to it.
  • People play videogames because they like it, or because they are not very social in the "real" world.
    Although I like to say physical world. Not like the things we experience in a videogame aren't real too, am I right?


    But... a lot of videogame players play videogames because they are not very good at socialising.
    In a videogame they might be able to break the ice quicker for whatever reason.
    And many of them are introverts to some extend.
    The best MMO is the type that allows all type of players to feel valued.
    Something that World of Warcraft has understood hence why it has survived to this day.
    Because it panders even to single player gamers in ways I cannot bother to mention here now.

    And then there is of course the existence of WoW's pathetic army of SIMPS, stockholm syndrom players and all other kinds of ADDICTS who are just too cowardly, uncreative or have grown too used to playing WoW, to ever going to quit no matter what happens in the future.
    Even if Ashes of Creation will come out and just SLAP... the people who cannot live without WoW anymore won't leave it.


    Even if Ashes would also give solo players a very warm welcome.
    What I think what Ashes should do is to somehow mention it to players when they approach type of content that is supposed to be tackled with a party of people.
    Just how WoW was in the beginning.

    " This is a quest recommended for about 2 to 3 players. "
    " This is a quest recommended for 5 players. "

    It's been some time but I remember even openworld Elite-mobs, being actually Elite-mobs which couldn't just be defeated by anybody. And that was GOOD, that made them look like much more serious business!


    So I do think Ashes should allow careful lonewolfs their place in the foodchain.
    But the Wolfs with a pack just go further. This is how it should be.
    If someone plays an MMO and is too cowardly to try and ask someone if their presence can be accepted in a group, which really is all which life boils down to, then they do not belong there. Easy as that.

    People are getting too weak, frail and anxious.
    And that is coming from me. Someone who hates to having to group up too innitially.
    I'm always worried I won't find anyone cause there is just no one who just wants to do some kind of content.
    This too started to happen more & more in WoW before it - maybe as a result to this - became more & more of a single player supporting game.
    m3h60maohz8f.jpg
  • DiamahtDiamaht Member, Braver of Worlds, Alpha One, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    Thokan wrote: »
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    Noaani wrote: »
    It really shouldn't be an issue at all. Ever.

    If you are forming a pickup group - in part or in full - have a healer.

    If you are grouping with friends, make sure one of your friends is a healer. If none of your friends are healers, be a healer.

    Now, some people may say that they prefer the gameplay of a tank or DPS. To these people my only comment is - if you are spending time in an MMO with your friends, and being a healer instead of another class is going to mean you don't enjoy your time, get better friends.

    how is that remotely fun ? also why do need to have friends to be able to compete ?


    Because its not a singleplayer.

    Do you realise the amount of people that dont like to take part in this guild thing ? why would you get a ridiculous advantage just for being that extravert gene pool ?

    The thing to realize here is that the people supporting the game, and the people that are developing the game DO want the tank/dps/healer dynamic to return to mmos. Its one of the reasons most of us got excited from the beginning. Its just not going to change.

    There could me more variety to choose from in healers, I'll give you that. So maybe future updates will add more healer archetypes (I'm sure they will), in the meantime the subclasses should provide a good amount of variety.

    But no, this won't be a solo game for the most part. And content that doesn't require tank or healer usually just means mobs that can't kill you. In other words solo. Name a game that does this that can't be solo'd.
  • LudulluLudullu Member, Alpha Two
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    Devs keep pandering to the zerglings and i'm tired of it.
    The solos ARE the zerglings. Soloable mmos lead to zergs, because it allows for anyone to just succeed. If anyone in the zerg is a successful player - the zerg is successful.

    Party-based mmos don't do that, because they're designed and balanced around those parties as being singular units, instead of "everybody gets the same reward".

    Zergs will most likely lose in Ashes exactly because it's gonna be a party game instead of a soloable mmo.
  • P0GG0P0GG0 Member, Alpha Two
    Yes you guys have a agenda, and you want that little advantage you built over the years to transfer into Ashes.

    throwing ur little buzzwords like multiplayer or MMORPG wont change the fact that you are forcing the solo player to interracial in some way with you're mafia guild.

    i'm curious on what open world pvp focused games you guys played ?
    the only recent one that actualy worked is albion online. Even ESO's large scale pvp zone seams empty and people would rather do arenas.
    WoW pvp is beyond ridiculous to get into
    New World is known for its fun pvp mechancis and the devs are only making content for the casual PvE player.


    Yall played a few MMOs and you think you understand of what a non instanced pvp looks like.

    forcing people into a trinity will just halt any kind of action until you get there. Then tryhard groups will bully the average casual player into zerging.

    if you dont push people into that nonsense you have a fun battle field with improvised opportunities or hardship. All you have to do is being aware of you're surrounding and make ur own decisions depending on how many allies or enemies are present at vision range.
    this is plenty enuf to have a ton of fun if the game rewards you for exploring enemy territories even if you don't kill anyone.
    this is way more fun than a never ending show or strength threw numbers or squad synergy.


  • LudulluLudullu Member, Alpha Two
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    Yes you guys have a agenda, and you want that little advantage you built over the years to transfer into Ashes.

    throwing ur little buzzwords like multiplayer or MMORPG wont change the fact that you are forcing the solo player to interracial in some way with you're mafia guild.
    Lol, I'm literally gonna be a solo player that will make a node guild to support other solo players. And I'll do that exactly because I want the game to make people rely on guilds and support from others. Because that makes the game more social.
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    i'm curious on what open world pvp focused games you guys played ?

    Yall played a few MMOs and you think you understand of what a non instanced pvp looks like.
    I played Lineage 2 and I know exactly how it is to fight against both the zerg and the highly organized small guilds as a zerg.

    Non-instanced dungeons are more fun when you're farming them with your mates that get together every time, instead of trying to find some randos who don't even know you and might not ever play with you again.
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    forcing people into a trinity will just halt any kind of action until you get there. Then tryhard groups will bully the average casual player into zerging.
    So you DO know that zergs are comprised of random casuals who barely play the game!

    And they lose to any coordinated group 9/10 times. Making people properly socialize into coordinated groups, and balancing the game around that, creates good guilds instead of those zerg ones you keep mentioning.

    You're literally asking for the thing you don't want.
  • NoaaniNoaani Member, Intrepid Pack, Alpha Two
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    Yes you guys have a agenda, and you want that little advantage you built over the years to transfer into Ashes.

    You also have an agenda - you want the game to be more to your liking.
  • DiamahtDiamaht Member, Braver of Worlds, Alpha One, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    edited December 2023
    Noaani wrote: »
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    Yes you guys have a agenda, and you want that little advantage you built over the years to transfer into Ashes.

    You also have an agenda - you want the game to be more to your liking.

    And we overwhelmingly don't want it to be his way.
  • NoaaniNoaani Member, Intrepid Pack, Alpha Two
    Diamaht wrote: »
    Noaani wrote: »
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    Yes you guys have a agenda, and you want that little advantage you built over the years to transfer into Ashes.

    You also have an agenda - you want the game to be more to your liking.

    And we overwhelmingly don't want it to be his way.

    Indeed.
  • OkeydokeOkeydoke Member, Alpha One, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    NiKr wrote: »
    so I made my own guild, made people play with themselves
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    you are forcing the solo player to interracial in some way with you're mafia guild.

    you guys r wild

  • LudulluLudullu Member, Alpha Two
    Okeydoke wrote: »
    you guys r wild
    But you see
    335bm8pjqbhe.gif
  • NiKr wrote: »
    Raven016 wrote: »
    Playing solo in mmos can be more a desire to feel the consequences of your own actions, to have your own progression. And reluctance to follow a leader.
    Then become that leader. That's what I did. I hated playing with other people, so I made my own guild, made people play with themselves, while I could still progress bit by bit.
    Before my previous post, I went and read what introvert means (the first paragraph)
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extraversion_and_introversion

    Now I read more and I see that there is Ambiversion:

    Most contemporary trait theories measure levels of extraversion-introversion as part of a single, continuous dimension of personality, with some scores near one end, and others near the halfway mark.[21] Ambiversion is falling more or less in the middle.[10][22]

    And

    Mistaking introversion for shyness is a common error. Introversion is a preference, while shyness stems from distress. Introverts prefer solitary to social activities, but do not necessarily fear social encounters like shy people do.[17
    [...]
    Cain describes how society is biased against introverts, and that, with people being taught from childhood that to be sociable is to be happy, introversion is now considered "somewhere between a disappointment and pathology".[19


    Anyway, Steven has a clear aim made up at least 7 years ago, of helping the introverts play together more, without pushing them into a guild.
    That is why he created the Node citizenship and denies the straightforward option of guild leaders to become mayors.
    It will be interesting to see this concept in game.
  • P0GG0P0GG0 Member, Alpha Two
    You guys are high on copium, the guild / trinity model suck's.
  • P0GG0 wrote: »
    You guys are high on copium, the guild / trinity model suck's.

    No they don't suck. What sucks is when they're the only viable options of play, which is rarely the case, although they're overly represented in the end-game stage usually.

    Be bold. Be brave. Roll a Tulnar !
  • Percimes wrote: »
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    You guys are high on copium, the guild / trinity model suck's.

    No they don't suck. What sucks is when they're the only viable options of play, which is rarely the case, although they're overly represented in the end-game stage usually.
    Why only 3?
    Let's invent a holly quadrality, quintality and sextality too.
  • P0GG0P0GG0 Member, Alpha Two
    edited December 2023
    Raven016 wrote: »
    Percimes wrote: »
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    You guys are high on copium, the guild / trinity model suck's.

    No they don't suck. What sucks is when they're the only viable options of play, which is rarely the case, although they're overly represented in the end-game stage usually.
    Why only 3?
    Let's invent a holly quadrality, quintality and sextality too.

    let be real this is not healthy game design.
  • P0GG0 wrote: »
    Raven016 wrote: »
    Percimes wrote: »
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    You guys are high on copium, the guild / trinity model suck's.

    No they don't suck. What sucks is when they're the only viable options of play, which is rarely the case, although they're overly represented in the end-game stage usually.
    Why only 3?
    Let's invent a holly quadrality, quintality and sextality too.

    let be real this is not healthy game design.

    To understand why 3 or 4 is a stable configuration, one must try creating a more complicated one too.
    Physical armor can be coupled with a magical armor too.

    But I know you actually mean that even 3 is too much and ideally one character should be sufficient when needed.
    It is clear to me why Steven wants the holly trinity and I see no way you can change his mind.
    With good balancing, we will not have any problems due to such specializations.
  • VyrilVyril Member, Alpha Two
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    You guys are high on copium, the guild / trinity model suck's.

    Dude. If you truly feel this way. Get off the bus now.

    Ashes isn't changing and you're just looking stupid.
  • VyrilVyril Member, Alpha Two
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    Vyril wrote: »
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    You guys are high on copium, the guild / trinity model suck's.

    Dude. If you truly feel this way. Get off the bus now.

    Ashes isn't changing and you're just looking stupid.

    truth sounds like hate to the one who does not want to hear it.

    thrown and liberty changed their whole combat system in a month. ashes is in alpha, do the math troll.

    And is p2w.

    You're not helping your cause. This comment might be your worst one yet.
  • LudulluLudullu Member, Alpha Two
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    thrown and liberty changed their whole combat system in a month. ashes is in alpha, do the math troll.
    TL changed it, because it's an NCsoft game, who're always about the money. Steven is making his game-child, so changing it completely would be the same as replacing your child with someone else.
  • Mag7spyMag7spy Member, Alpha Two
    edited December 2023
    lp
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    You guys are high on copium, the guild / trinity model suck's.

    55ih8n3va67f.png

    If you join me I promise you can get revenge on the people you don't like.
  • P0GG0P0GG0 Member, Alpha Two
    look at this, they already targeting healers week one.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-fEq6exo9io

    yall dont know anything.
  • Mag7spyMag7spy Member, Alpha Two
    @P0GG0 It is your time for revenge.... join me, and as you work for ME you can have the privilege to destroy all the people you want...
  • LudulluLudullu Member, Alpha Two
    P0GG0 wrote: »
    look at this, they already targeting healers week one.

    yall dont know anything.
    What a surprise, high value kills get made first (more like, attempted). Make it easy for tanks to protect healers and now tanks are high value kills.

    Also, his party/raid ui is not visible in that video and I don't remember if TL's healers heal just party or anyone in their aoe. If Ashes sticks to the party limitations - healers might be lower value kills, because it'd be easier to burst down an aoe burst dpser than trying to kill a healer under the protection of a tank.

    To me it seems like you don't know anything :)
Sign In or Register to comment.