Greetings, glorious testers!
Check out Alpha Two Announcements here to see the latest news on Alpha Two.
Check out general Announcements here to see the latest news on Ashes of Creation & Intrepid Studios.
To get the quickest updates regarding Alpha Two, connect your Discord and Intrepid accounts here.
Check out Alpha Two Announcements here to see the latest news on Alpha Two.
Check out general Announcements here to see the latest news on Ashes of Creation & Intrepid Studios.
To get the quickest updates regarding Alpha Two, connect your Discord and Intrepid accounts here.
Comments
It seems reasonable that there’s a multitude of factors contributing to why, when, and how metas develop, having only played archeage a few short months with low intensity, I’m not really equipped to comment on that particular case. What I can and have commented on is the evolution of other MMOs that employed heavy data analysis and how that analysis changed the game and the culture of those games.
I’m glad we’re I agreement on wanting a variety of play, but it’s hard for me to believe that the existence of a meter won’t be something that is used to for people to point to a build and say “this build useless, get rid of it.” The longer we can prevent the discovery of end game optimization, the better. There is no reason to aid the obsoletion of 55 classes.
The anecdotal evidence of builds being produced in archage beta and persisting for years seems, with all due respect, like a red herring.
And I can point out that Darkfall had a higher combat tracker usage than Archeage.
So, between these two games, the one with more people using combat trackers had the more interesting meta
But, I dont think that was the point you were trying to make.
What hud elements?
If you can see a combat tracker during combat, you are using it wrong.
Yeah, out of all the DPS Meters I have used my favourite was a chat link which opened a chat panel and then allowed the sections to be clicked on and browsed. Wasn't seen until the end of a fight.
Mine - not surprisingly - is ACT.
It is it's own application, that you either run in the background and alt tab to, run on a separate monitor, or run on a separate computer.
I always just used to run it in the background, because as you point out, there is literally never a need to look at a combat tracker during a fight.
It should also be a good middle ground for the pro and anti DPS meter sides of this discussion. This whole discussion (10th thread this year about it) is just a ping pong game of demanding a DPS meter or nothing at all.
So why not accept the middle ground already provided by Intrepid and have a game that everyone can enjoy?
No one is really demanding combat trackers. What we are (or at least, I am) doing is stating outright that there will be combat trackers used with Ashes, and pointing out that it is not in the games best interest to not allow these to be widely used.
Part of pointing that out is explaining why some reasons people have for not wanting them are not really applicable. No one has come forward with a valid reason to not include combat trackers built in to the game - let alone simply allowing third party ones - that isn't built on a demonstrably false assumption.
And by no one, I am including Steven.
Reason: Everyone plays on an even playing field with them not in the game.
For those that decide to use them anyway, they risk getting banned. It follows the theme of the game - which is Risk/Reward.
Your argument: If they are included in the game, everyone gets to use them, so even playing field.
Which is not true, because some people refuse to use them, so they are automatically at a disadvantage on day one.
If combat trackers are added, they might as well just take builds out of the game and just have cookie cutter classes that all do the same damage/healing/buffs/AoE and whatnot across the board, because after a year of combat trackers, if not sooner, everyone will be playing close to the same builds anyway... why have diversity if one tool is going to get rid of it?
Just be straight and say - I don't like it so I don't want it
― Plato
Would absolutely love to hear you explain how they're gonna ban me for reading my own combat log. Or how they'd even be able to tell. Steven already said we will be able to export our combat log and analyze it for our own purposes. That means third party tools will exist. That means DPS meters will exist. You're trying to hard to force your own bygone era of playing onto modern players. Gaming has changed, and you haven't. Let go of the past. You clearly haven't played a game that has made use of combat meters, and likely haven't played any high level of MMO content at all. Your feedback on this topic is nonsensical to the point where I have a difficult time even finding a way to address it in a way that you could comprehend. There have been a lot of extremely great points made in this thread, and you just repeat yourself over and over, ignoring them.
Trying to maintain build diversity by obfuscation is nowhere near sustainable.
By your logic, that means Intrepid shouldn't include group content, because that means people that refuse to use it are not playing on an even playing field.
People that refuse to group have every bit as valid a reason to do so as people that refuse to use a combat tracker.
If it is built in to the game and you refuse to use it, you are making the decision to refuse that even playing field - that doesn't mean an even playing field wasn't offered to you.
No need to explain how people will get banned, as I know not everyone will. You for example may get away with for the life of the game... As I said, there is a risk of getting banned, it is not a certainty that you will.
As for forcing people to play by "my era", I am not trying to do anything.. Steven made the rules, not me, I just choose to abide by them. Which also means you have not read any of my other posts, which basically say if they were available (in game), I would use a personal one. Not calling you out on that, there are quite a few posts to read through to find that info.
As for great points being made.. you do not have to convince me on how well meters work, I know how well they work and that they can be a helpful tool. I am only arguing on the side of the game developer because that is his vision of how how he wants the game to be played. If Steven says he does not want them in game... then so be it, they do not belong in a game where the developer says they do not. I like the fact they will not be in game but also realize that players will use them anyway. If players want to go around the system, they will. It has been a part of playing Pc games since the beginning basically.
Below is not a true story, just an example.
One of my biggest pet peeves in MMOs is having to run a long distance and then realizing I forgot to grab an item I needed. So teleporters, to me, are amazing.... This game will not have a vast teleportation system. I have accepted this and moved on. If they were added on later in the game, I would be very happy, but I understand Steven's reasons on why he does not want them in now, or never. If there was a 3rd party tool that I could download, that would teleport me to wherever I wanted as long as I was not in battle... I would not use it, simply because that is not how the game was built. If I did use a tool like that, we both know people would complain, because it gives me an advantage over those who do not use one. This is how I feel about meters. Again... as stated above, if meters were in game, I would use one for personal use. Just as if teleporters were in game, people would use them as well.
Meters get a player to his Min/Max abilities faster than just playing the game straight up.
Teleport addons get a player to his destination faster than just playing the game straight up.
Again, this was just the quickest example I could come up with that was sorta closely relatable. It is not to be taken seriously, again just an example.
Most importantly - that's what Steven believes. Which is why he's not including them.
Toxicity will be in the game with or without damage meters , it would really make no difference. Players are going to have access to the combat data, so a meta will happen and gatekeeping , its not something that can be avoided.
I definitely see what you are getting at, but group play has been the backbone of almost every MMO ever released, where as meters have not been. So if group play has been a mainstay in that genre, and someone refuses to play in groups, you are correct... it was offered to them. Meters are not the same thing, they are not 100% needed to play the game. They are only 100% needed to play the games that offer you the style of play you like. For example WoW, where meters are, as I hear, 100% needed to compete. But I see what you are getting at.. which is funny, because I gave an example in my post above this one about teleporters which is kinds trying to argue the same thing from the opposite point of view.
If it is all going to happen anyway... then why does there need to be a meter in game? There is another fact in life I can give as well... Everyone on Earth will die, this is a given... this does not mean you give everyone a tool to make it happen faster than it will naturally. Patience will get everyone there in the end.
I suspect we’re at the point in this conversation where some are just arguing for the sake of arguing. At least on the point of declaring min-max cheating and calling for bans. Those sound like hyperbolic statements.
So if some feel so strongly about min-maxing, how about no combat logs, no health or damage indicators and keeping all in game feedback more abstract? That way there are no numbers to game the system and therefore no need for parsers. Everything would be by feel or trial and error. So through experience you might know this attack can one shot a cow, but it takes three to bring down a bear. Is this more agreeable for those who are concerned about cheating?
And combat trackers have been available in every MMO ever released - even the ones that try to make that not so.
Perhaps I should point out that my statement applies to everything in an MMO, not just group content. I have known some ultra-religious people that refused to do any religion based content, which puts them at a disadvantage in many games.
I also had a raid member that couldn't do content with large spiders. This was fine until he needed to kill a large spider on a raid in order to progress through content. This put our whole guild at a disadvantage
Point is, if it is available to all to use, then all have a level playing field. It is what each of us do with that playing field that then matters.
You don't need a DPS Meter in WoW if you only take high iLevel Players. It is gear dependant more than Meter Dependant. A lot of groups will have a DPS Meter open during fights but it is never really used if you build the groups right.
This is where you really get on my nerves when it comes to this argument.
You act as though just because someone used a tracker in every single MMO, sanctioned or not... it is officially a mainstay in MMOs...
Again.. not the same thing... but it gets the point across.... Wall hacks, and aimbots are in every single FPS game ever made... they should officially put them in all of them to even the playing field. Neither your statement or mine, make sense.
So what if AoC is the same way?
I said toxicity will be present without DPS meters , DPS meters will not make it worst or better. Really what kind of players do you think your going to be playing with in a open world pvp game?
You keep focusing on the wrong part of people's posts.
Previously, I pointed out that if it is in the game and available to all, it is a level playing field. You focused on the specific example I gave, instead of the actual point I made.
Then in this post, rather than taking on board the reiteration of that point, you are focusing on the part of it that gets you pissed off.
The gear level will determine what content you do, not because of gear gateways but due to the repair mechanics. I have considered the prospects and I'm not certain I can be bothered to maintain a full set of Legendary Gear. I could push myself and get full legendary gear (Crafted) but I fear my time will be taken up fully by maintaining the armour. This doesn't even relate to Parsers in anyway, just the planned systems in place. Fortunately, you only lose durability when you die so you could just wear legendary gear for Sieges, Caravan Defence and Guild Wars (though Guild Wars are open world and you could be killed by someone not in the enemy guild). I do enjoy theory crafting and I have not used a Parser to theory craft so far.
Whereas games that don't have them or don't allow their use for toxic reasons have the best communities in the entire MMO genre and often retain the most players in the long term due to fun builds not being essentially banned from the game because it does 5% less damage.
Min Maxing happens either way, but in games that don't have combat trackers the players understand more of the game than ones that do. Since they've tried every single build in the game over it's lifespan. In games that have combat trackers they often don't give every build a chance and ban them from the game preemptively. They don't take into account that the damage or healing are lower for other reasons.
That bided time helps people come to terms with what builds people want to play. Then in time people understand to remove the extremely bad ones cuz they are often neither fun to play or remotely relevant. However, with combat trackers the builds that get phased out of the game are ones that otherwise people would have used. They tend to phase too many and it's often so many that everything interesting about the game is removed as well.
I want the MIn Maxing to be hard to do because it often takes so much time to do manually that it doesn't ruin the game as it is happening.
DPS meter mentality values the stats over the community. Anti DPS mentality values the community over the stats.
U.S. East
@Yuyukoyay
What games *SPECIFICALLY* are you talking about here?
You make claims of games that have them that only have one or two guilds per server. Which game are you talking about?
You make claims of games that dont have them and have the best communities. Which game are you talking about?
Of the 20+ MMO's I have played, the game with the best community (EQ2) had very high combat tracker use, and the game with the worst community (Archeage) had the least amount of combat tracker use.
This is why I want to know specifically what games you are talking g about, as your comments are diametrically opposed to my experiences.