Glorious Alpha Two Testers!

Phase I of Alpha Two testing will occur on weekends. Each weekend is scheduled to start on Fridays at 10 AM PT and end on Sundays at 10 PM PT. Find out more here.

Check out Alpha Two Announcements here to see the latest Alpha Two news and update notes.

Our quickest Alpha Two updates are in Discord. Testers with Alpha Two access can chat in Alpha Two channels by connecting your Discord and Intrepid accounts here.

Cosmetic Shop is P2W

11112131416

Comments

  • DygzDygz Member, Braver of Worlds, Kickstarter, Alpha One, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    edited August 2022
    Azherae wrote: »

    One more time.

    Two people, approx equal skill at RP.

    Two knights for options. One slot.

    One Knight has Cosmetic, the other doesn't.

    I will believe that you would go 'Well we shouldn't give any special advantage to Carl because he actually looks the part, let's flip a coin'.

    I'm just surprised you've never met anyone who doesn't flip the coin.
    But... that is not a thing.
    Especially not in Ashes.
  • Mag7spyMag7spy Member, Alpha Two
    @Dygz in any mmorpg you have played have you seen any member turned away because of the visual look of their armor or weapons (not in context of stats but only because of the look, not including clown looks etc)
  • @MybroViajero Wow, you follow my posts and remember it from like six months ago? I’m blushing…
  • Mag7spyMag7spy Member, Alpha Two
    edited August 2022
    Honestly was not aware they keep posting the same topic, like i said before they used the most toxic title possible this time.


    swyjmlk04jhp.png
  • WarthWarth Member, Alpha Two
    Can we just let this die? Everything was said. Time to let this fade away
  • Samson1Samson1 Member
    edited August 2022
    I know some of you won't watch these short video clips (or may disregard this reply altogether) just because of who is speaking in them but I think they do a pretty good job of showing a tiny window into why cosmetic shops throw a wrench into how some people enjoy MMORPGs or multiplayer games in general. This post is also meant to be lighthearted and, if not persuasive, at least maybe a little entertaining. :)

    Whenever You Can Buy Something, That Something No Longer Matters

    https://www.youtube.com/clip/UgkxJjJLg_KLSNOV0WCTEpGsAR6ZYlEcqXJg

    How many of you guys were proud of the first character that you got to max level in an MMO? Let me ask you another question... Would you feel the same way if you just knew that somebody else standing right next to you, at the same level that you are, bought it?

    Whenever you can buy something... that something no longer matters. That's why I don't care about TCG mounts or store mounts in my Mount Offs. It's not impressive to me that somebody has a Swift Spectral Tiger. Wow! You have ten thousand dollars... Congratulations! That doesn't mean [poop] to me.



    This is My Opinion...It's Subjective

    I want to make sure everybody understands this... This is my opinion. It's completely arbitrary. There is no like... this is not written on one of the tablets on the side of the [frickin'] mountain... that God wrote the Ten Commandments next to. This is my arbitrary line in the sand that I draw. It's subjective. The thing is once you abstract things enough, having a computer becomes Pay to Win. Buying the game becomes Pay to Win. So I'm not looking for an endless [Russian Nesting Dolls] of like [fricking] abstractions to obfuscate the conversation. Let's watch the video. People willingly misunderstand what I'm saying in order to try to catch me in some sort of logical fallacy.

    https://www.youtube.com/clip/UgkxybVdbKi-Jlb5DbGc7TImb7NXXaIYvp3h


    Both Answers Are Right... It All Depends on How You Define Pay 2 Win

    A lot of people take sides in this argument, and feel fully vindicated in saying that Lost Ark is Pay to Win or Lost Ark is not Pay to Win. But here's the thing... Both answers are right. It all depends on how you define Pay to Win. So when you see two people or more arguing about a game like this being Pay to Win, make sure they've at least agreed upon the definition first because 99% of the time they're arguing from different platforms... and they're both right, so neither of them is gonna back down. So anyway, that's where we are.

    https://www.youtube.com/clip/UgkxHU6z0BlAMti6HshDydu_yZq0Vc-AYubm


    Just a funny video but still relevant to the conversation and kinda ties everything together... :D

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HJp8pRTFVe4


    Like I already said before in prior replies, I understand that some people have no qualms with a cosmetic store in AoC. And I totally respect that... But that doesn't take away the fact that some players feel the store impacts their playing experience in a negative way.
    sig-Samson-Final.gif
  • This content has been removed.
  • Mag7spyMag7spy Member, Alpha Two
    Samson wrote: »
    I know some of you won't watch these short video clips (or may disregard this reply altogether) just because of who is speaking in them but I think they do a pretty good job of showing a tiny window into why cosmetic shops throw a wrench into how some people enjoy MMORPGs or multiplayer games in general. This post is also meant to be lighthearted and, if not persuasive, at least maybe a little entertaining. :)

    Whenever You Can Buy Something, That Something No Longer Matters

    https://www.youtube.com/clip/UgkxJjJLg_KLSNOV0WCTEpGsAR6ZYlEcqXJg

    How many of you guys were proud of the first character that you got to max level in an MMO? Let me ask you another question... Would you feel the same way if you just knew that somebody else standing right next to you, at the same level that you are, bought it?

    Whenever you can buy something... that something no longer matters. That's why I don't care about TCG mounts or store mounts in my Mount Offs. It's not impressive to me that somebody has a Swift Spectral Tiger. Wow! You have ten thousand dollars... Congratulations that doesn't mean [poop] to me.



    This is My Opinion...It's Subjective

    I want to make sure everybody understands this... This is my opinion. It's completely arbitrary. There is no like... this is not written on one of the tablets on the side of the [frickin'] mountain... that God wrote the Ten Commandments next to. This is my arbitrary line in the sand that I draw. It's subjective. The thing is once you abstract things enough, having a computer becomes Pay to Win. Buying the game becomes Pay to Win. So I'm not looking for an endless [Russian Nesting Dolls] of extra of of like [fricking] abstractions to obfuscate the conversation. Let's watch the video. People willingly misunderstand what I'm saying in order to try to catch me in some sort of logical fallacy.

    https://www.youtube.com/clip/UgkxybVdbKi-Jlb5DbGc7TImb7NXXaIYvp3h


    Both Answers Are Right... It All Depends on How You Define Pay 2 Win

    A lot of people take sides in this argument, and feel fully vindicated in saying that Lost Ark is Pay to Win or Lost Ark is not Pay to Win. But here's the thing... Both answers are right. It all depends on how you define Pay to Win. So when you see two people or more arguing about a game like this being Pay to Win, make sure they've at least agreed upon the definition first because 99% of the time they're arguing from different platforms... and they're both right, so neither of them is gonna back down. So anyway, that's where we are.

    https://www.youtube.com/clip/UgkxHU6z0BlAMti6HshDydu_yZq0Vc-AYubm


    Just a funny video but still relevant to the conversation and kinda ties everything together... :D

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HJp8pRTFVe4


    Like I already said before in prior replies, I understand that some people have no qualms with a cosmetic store in AoC. And I totally respect that... But that doesn't take away the fact that some players feel the store impacts their playing experience in a negative way.

    I enjoy his content I have no issues with him lol. I can understand hoe people feels the experience is lessoned when you can buy stuff from the shop. Im sure everyone understands that but that isn't the issue at hand.

    The issue is changing your look with money being called P2W. That being the focus of the discussion and being used makes people question or combat why they are saying it. If you use a buzzword you get the strong reaction you are aiming for. Which prevents a actual discussion even more so when you triple down on it.
  • George_BlackGeorge_Black Member, Intrepid Pack, Alpha Two
    edited August 2022
    Warth wrote: »
    Can we just let this die? Everything was said. Time to let this fade away

    No, we cant let this die.
    We needed azhrae and her meaningless posts to give this topic a second wind. She supported the OP (who was shamelessly attacked from all these bored people for 14 pages just for being annoying for her title choice) and now this can reach another 14. Just to be a contrarian she gave this topic the fresh breath it needed right when it was about to die.

    People should be embarrashed. Azhrae for her level of pretentiousness and everybody else for buckling under her fluff, not calling her out, rather tippy-toeing around pseudo-philosophical meanings of p2w.

    I gotta say, the change of language by some people here when addressing the OP and when addressing the crap azhrae brought into this is striking.

    This is one more of those topics that shows that gamers deserved the lip service of previous studios and the lack of communication. Why? Because people act like a circus online.
  • NoaaniNoaani Member, Intrepid Pack, Alpha Two
    Samson wrote: »
    Both Answers Are Right... It All Depends on How You Define Pay 2 Win.
    I disagree.

    What matters is how Intrepid define it.
  • This content has been removed.
  • DolyemDolyem Member, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    Gahd damn I have been away doing stuff but I stand by what I said earlier. Cosmetics aren't gameplay, therefore they cant be pay to win. And winning is a factor set by the games design, not by a personal goal. So personal RP "advantages" are completely irrelevant.
    GJjUGHx.gif
  • DolyemDolyem Member, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    Otr wrote: »
    Dolyem wrote: »
    I forgot I made this awhile ago

    gjePgqt.jpg

    You made it 15 years ago? :smiley:

    Say what?
    GJjUGHx.gif
  • Noaani wrote: »
    Samson wrote: »
    Both Answers Are Right... It All Depends on How You Define Pay 2 Win.
    I disagree.

    What matters is how Intrepid define it.

    I agree with you that they have the right to do whatever they want with their game. I'm also allowed to have an opinion and it doesn't bother me how popular or unpopular it may be.
    sig-Samson-Final.gif
  • Mag7spyMag7spy Member, Alpha Two
    Warth wrote: »
    Can we just let this die? Everything was said. Time to let this fade away

    No, we cant let this die.
    We needed azhrae and her meaningless posts to give this topic a second wind. She supported the OP (who was shamelessly attacked from all these bored people for 14 pages just for being annoying for her title choice) and now this can reach another 14. Just to be a contrarian she gave this topic the fresh breath it needed right when it was about to die.

    People should be embarrashed. Azhrae for her level of pretentiousness and everybody else for buckling under her fluff, not calling her out, rather tippy-toeing around pseudo-philosophical meanings of p2w.

    I gotta say, the change of language by some people here when addressing the OP and when addressing the crap azhrae brought into this is striking.

    This is one more of those topics that shows that gamers deserved the lip service of previous studios and the lack of communication. Why? Because people act like a circus online.

    I called her out on it and even tried to explain but there is only so much I can do. I'm looking through the old thread trying to find out why azhrae suddenly swapped sides and how to burn this thread down like the last one.

    x6n56fdwdgcm.png
  • Lmfao. You are all pathetic. You choose to ignore the blatant lie that this video game won’t have pay to win because it makes the milk you constantly suckle from Steven’s teat of promises taste sour. You all have sat on this post all day repeating the same limited and subjective opinion that cosmetics don’t affect your precious number score, so they must be meaningless in a role playing adventure game. You don’t have an original thought in your head and you have probably never tried to see life from someone else’s point of view. Just regurgitating whatever makes your reality less pitiful on discussion boards that “piss you off”. Keep throwing your money at this game that isn’t even out yet and has no release date in sight so they can give you your meaningless little forum titles and keep you soothed as they keep convincing you they need even more of it.
  • NoaaniNoaani Member, Intrepid Pack, Alpha Two
    Samson wrote: »
    Noaani wrote: »
    Samson wrote: »
    Both Answers Are Right... It All Depends on How You Define Pay 2 Win.
    I disagree.

    What matters is how Intrepid define it.

    I agree with you that they have the right to do whatever they want with their game. I'm also allowed to have an opinion and it doesn't bother me how popular or unpopular it may be.

    You are allowed your own opinion - but only on subjective things.

    You are not allowed your own opinion on objective things.

    The meaning behind Intrepids statements in regards to pay to win are objective, not subjective.

    People are allowed to hold the opinion that they do not like that objective reality, that is fine. However, they are not allowed to have the opinion that intrepid meant to say something that Intrepid did not say.
  • Iridianny wrote: »
    Lmfao. You are all pathetic. You choose to ignore the blatant lie that this video game won’t have pay to win because it makes the milk you constantly suckle from Steven’s teat of promises taste sour. You all have sat on this post all day repeating the same limited and subjective opinion that cosmetics don’t affect your precious number score, so they must be meaningless in a role playing adventure game. You don’t have an original thought in your head and you have probably never tried to see life from someone else’s point of view. Just regurgitating whatever makes your reality less pitiful on discussion boards that “piss you off”. Keep throwing your money at this game that isn’t even out yet and has no release date in sight so they can give you your meaningless little forum titles and keep you soothed as they keep convincing you they need even more of it.

    tenor.gif
    sig-Samson-Final.gif
  • Mag7spyMag7spy Member, Alpha Two
    edited August 2022
    Iridianny wrote: »
    Lmfao. You are all pathetic. You choose to ignore the blatant lie that this video game won’t have pay to win because it makes the milk you constantly suckle from Steven’s teat of promises taste sour. You all have sat on this post all day repeating the same limited and subjective opinion that cosmetics don’t affect your precious number score, so they must be meaningless in a role playing adventure game. You don’t have an original thought in your head and you have probably never tried to see life from someone else’s point of view. Just regurgitating whatever makes your reality less pitiful on discussion boards that “piss you off”. Keep throwing your money at this game that isn’t even out yet and has no release date in sight so they can give you your meaningless little forum titles and keep you soothed as they keep convincing you they need even more of it.

    Lmfao. You are all pathetic.

    Since you are going to insult me again....I gotta bring that fire with Natasha


    fopubsnhaua0.png
  • Mag7spyMag7spy Member, Alpha Two
    edited August 2022
    Iridianny wrote: »
    Lmfao. You are all pathetic. You choose to ignore the blatant lie that this video game won’t have pay to win because it makes the milk you constantly suckle from Steven’s teat of promises taste sour. You all have sat on this post all day repeating the same limited and subjective opinion that cosmetics don’t affect your precious number score, so they must be meaningless in a role playing adventure game. You don’t have an original thought in your head and you have probably never tried to see life from someone else’s point of view. Just regurgitating whatever makes your reality less pitiful on discussion boards that “piss you off”. Keep throwing your money at this game that isn’t even out yet and has no release date in sight so they can give you your meaningless little forum titles and keep you soothed as they keep convincing you they need even more of it.

    This is the most real you have ever been, i almost want to recruit you since I can see the evil in your heart. You would make a good pvper.
  • This content has been removed.
  • Mag7spyMag7spy Member, Alpha Two
    Time to sleep, expecting to see another 5 pages when I wake up lmao.
  • DolyemDolyem Member, Alpha Two, Early Alpha Two
    Iridianny wrote: »
    Lmfao. You are all pathetic. You choose to ignore the blatant lie that this video game won’t have pay to win because it makes the milk you constantly suckle from Steven’s teat of promises taste sour. You all have sat on this post all day repeating the same limited and subjective opinion that cosmetics don’t affect your precious number score, so they must be meaningless in a role playing adventure game. You don’t have an original thought in your head and you have probably never tried to see life from someone else’s point of view. Just regurgitating whatever makes your reality less pitiful on discussion boards that “piss you off”. Keep throwing your money at this game that isn’t even out yet and has no release date in sight so they can give you your meaningless little forum titles and keep you soothed as they keep convincing you they need even more of it.

    Until you provide a legitimate argument, I will repeat my previous statement. Your entire argument is based on how you feel, not on how the game is designed. Your argument would be relevant if the games design for winning was based on specific cosmetics to collect or collecting them all. Your personal interests and goals mean nothing in the grand scheme of an established design of a games world mechanics if they do not align with each other.

    That being said, this quoted comment by you leaves me no choice but to purchase another cosmetic purely for the sake of being petty.

    pAqdmFw.gif
    GJjUGHx.gif
  • IridiannyIridianny Member
    edited August 2022
    Natasha wrote: »
    Iridianny wrote: »
    Lmfao. You are all pathetic. You choose to ignore the blatant lie that this video game won’t have pay to win because it makes the milk you constantly suckle from Steven’s teat of promises taste sour. You all have sat on this post all day repeating the same limited and subjective opinion that cosmetics don’t affect your precious number score, so they must be meaningless in a role playing adventure game. You don’t have an original thought in your head and you have probably never tried to see life from someone else’s point of view. Just regurgitating whatever makes your reality less pitiful on discussion boards that “piss you off”. Keep throwing your money at this game that isn’t even out yet and has no release date in sight so they can give you your meaningless little forum titles and keep you soothed as they keep convincing you they need even more of it.

    Yes.
    We choose to embrace that your opinion is wrong.
    And because we're not smooth-brained idiots...

    Glad you agree so blatantly.
    Also, that’s not something you “embrace,” opinions are opinions and typically aren’t right or wrong unless you are speaking from a moral standpoint.
    Lastly, I find that hard to believe considering your picture alone is someone in a cheap wig sticking a game controller up their nose while staring off into the distance mouth agape.
  • MybroViajeroMybroViajero Member, Alpha Two
    edited August 2022
    Iridianny wrote: »
    Lmfao. You are all pathetic. You choose to ignore the blatant lie that this video game won’t have pay to win because it makes the milk you constantly suckle from Steven’s teat of promises taste sour. You all have sat on this post all day repeating the same limited and subjective opinion that cosmetics don’t affect your precious number score, so they must be meaningless in a role playing adventure game. You don’t have an original thought in your head and you have probably never tried to see life from someone else’s point of view. Just regurgitating whatever makes your reality less pitiful on discussion boards that “piss you off”. Keep throwing your money at this game that isn’t even out yet and has no release date in sight so they can give you your meaningless little forum titles and keep you soothed as they keep convincing you they need even more of it.

    It's thanks to people like you and comments like the one you wrote that I have inspiration to make more memes, thank you sincerely :)

    mTCq5RI.png
    EDym4eg.png
  • This content has been removed.
  • @Natasha Here’s something I know it will be hard for you to understand, so read it slowly, but… I don’t actually care if people agree with me.
  • This content has been removed.
Sign In or Register to comment.