Glorious Alpha Two Testers!
Alpha Two Phase III testing has begun! During this phase, our realms will be open every day, and we'll only have downtime for updates and maintenance. We'll keep everyone up-to-date about downtimes in Discord.
If you have Alpha Two, you can download the game launcher here, and we encourage you to join us on our Official Discord Server for the most up to date testing news.
Alpha Two Phase III testing has begun! During this phase, our realms will be open every day, and we'll only have downtime for updates and maintenance. We'll keep everyone up-to-date about downtimes in Discord.
If you have Alpha Two, you can download the game launcher here, and we encourage you to join us on our Official Discord Server for the most up to date testing news.
Comments
Ashes could easily extend city to city timers to last 3-4 weeks. Both Negative and Positive faction for players within regions. Basing this on players actions.. Overtime this would result in different sides and would naturally form factions.... ,, But that is a whole other Thread....
Riverland vs the Anvils! Coming soon!
Never see it happening, but would be pretty great imo!
Was only trying to compare PVP rewards vs PVE rewards. Looks like we got a bit derailed, my bad... At any rate it looks like they are already working on PVP Augments for AOC,, which are in many ways the same thing as many of DAOC realm abilities. So I guess my suggestion was a mute point...
New News for me....
But this would be a yet another 180 on Steven's initially presented design, because back in the day he said that he doesn't like endless wars where "people kill each other just to kill each other". Kinda fucking ironic that he then added lawless zone design into the game, but that's also a topic for a whole different thread.
For one absolutely nobody asks for your opinions, you always like to self insert yourself everywhere, and here we are back with the gaslight, if you call harassing people critiquing sure. Let me tell you, i couldnt care less about your opinions ok.
For your information, i mean if by building you mean crafting gear, there is like A LOT (of people) who deeply dislike crafting (and pveing to get gear on top of that), also are you trying to tell me, the games that did such, they shouldnt have, besides being proven its completely fine there is no issue whatsoever?
If the developers wanted Ashes to function as a faction game, they would build it as a faction game.
Saying "if you do this convoluted thing your game could function in a way you specifically do not want it to function" isn't the best comment I've heard.
Ashes is being specifically and purposefully designed to NOT have factions.
To your first point, players that dislike crafting can pay others to do it for them. It is not as if any one player will be able to make everything they want to use in game, so even those that are crafting will need other ceafters to make things for them.
To your second point, sure, other games have done it - but tuat isn't a very ggood argument. When you say "other games" in the context of something that Intrepid have ststed their intent on, you are saying you think Ashes should change to be less like Ashes, and more like these "other games".
If you want to use "other games do it" as a reason why Intrepid should do something, then you need to accept that same defense when other people make that same argument The problem is, those "other games" include games like WoW.
Ashes is not trying to be other games - it is trying to be Ashes. One of the things is that means is that the cast majority of items (gear, consumables, mounts, ships etc) will be player made. Sure, "other games" that are not this game may have done this differently, but they are other games.
"Ashes is being specifically and purposefully designed to NOT have factions." Noaani
"If the developers wanted Ashes to function as a faction game, they would build it as a faction game." Noaani
Religion is a "faction based" system they are planning on adding to game..(Have already started to adding to testing)
Town Citizenship is a "faction based" system in game. Your Rep with a town is your Faction with the town
(already in testing)
No these are not the same predefined faction "race" base system you see in other MMOs, but are indeed faction based systems in the game AOC....
It is ok not the first time you have completely mislead people in this thread.. Noanii
" But that is a whole other Thread...Gardosien ." What part of that statement lead you to believe I was looking for your feedback in this thread? ,,,, You are Just Trolling again,,, Getting really old Dude, and not cool....
The fact that other PVX , Sandbox MMO Have done it,(it worked for them) and maintain a player base for over 20 years, is a dam good argument to look into , "what did they do right".. Sorry you are not able to wrap your little head around that concept.
Thanks for providing Clarity that Ashes is not trying to be like other games , it is trying to be Ashes... We all did not know that.
Again,,,,, This thread was about Balancing PVP and PVE rewards in a PVX game, you have seemed to miss the mark in a majority of your posts. Noaani.
Yeeeeah... is like i havent played an mmo before, there was no crafting in there or anything.... [ while what i suggested still existed as well go figure]
And in truth i come here to give feedback aka suggestions/ideas which that is exactly what feedback is for (imagine) not exactly to argue with individuals that clearly do not show to possess much of a brain...
Also '... you are saying you think Ashes should change to be less like Ashes, and more like these "other games".' interesting that sentence inst it, is like i havent seen others do precisely that in here (smells like hypocrisy) besides correction i didnt you did.
'Ashes is not trying to be other games' meanwhile having systems influenced by other mmos/games SUUURE
Btw you still make a loooootta sense.
Forums have a ignore function, For anyone wanting to know...(seems to work pretty good)
And L2 is that exact sandbox mmo with pure pvx where everyone has to both farm mobs and pvp for them.
It has rewards through sieges, guild wars, territorial wars (with a really valuable gear item as a reward) and general pvp skirmishes in the open world.
ALL OF THAT w/o default factions or lawless zones. And yet all of you "pvpers" keep saying "no, that's not a good example for what Ashes should be! It should be like MY game!"(which is then real fucking different from what Ashes has been promised to be).
AA is a faction game. Steven obviously loves AA as much as L2, if not more, yet he hasn't copied that part of its design into Ashes. I'd imagine there was a reason for that. And sure, "everything is subject to change" and all that, but yall have already gotten the lawless zones which are a parallel to AA's pvp zones, afaik, so PvPers are already getting more content for themselves. And majority of that content is planned to be the most rewarding part of the game btw.
Btw Have I missed a patchnote or smth? Where exactly have they updated religion in A2?
And also, as for its factionness. So far I highly doubt that'll be the actual case with that design. If anything, all the talk about religion-related designs has always been purely pve. Religious nodes are all about quests and religious node superpower is pve catacombs. I've always hoped we'd have holy wars or smth.
Hell, there's literally this from 2022:
PvP wars between religions are not a planned feature for the game.[16]
https://ashesofcreation.wiki/Religions
You keep saying that yet you keep responding to me. I appreciate that you care so deeply about all of my opinions and suggestions
I mean, the comment about not everyone liking crafting that you made does come across as being from someone that has only ever dabbled in MMO's before.
Feedback is commentary on what has been done, not suggestions on how to do it differently.
If you say something along the lines of "I don't think PvP is rewarding enough in Ashes", that is feedback. As soon as you suggest ways to remedy that, it is no longer feedback, but now falls in to the realm of "suggestion".
Intrepid have asked for player feedback, they have never asked for player suggestions.
When you make a toon, in testing you pick a Religion during that time... In game since phase3, not much more added with atm that I know of.... But clearly it is a start...
And to be clear, Ashes has not promised very little, anything at this point, because everything is Subject to change
IMO
I, for one, am expecting a more Isekai-style Anime MMO, which favors my archetype statistically.
Something like:
"Ashes of Another World: I Was Transported To Verra And Became A High Evasion Priestess Of A Border Settlement And Saved The Country With My Powers of Alchemical Creation".
Then all the people who don't like the character models will either no longer have a problem or have a really different one depending on their disposition.
.. uwu
I can finally be the Beater I was always meant to be
What the Bloody hell are your talking about! You followed this game for how long and posted how may times on this forum... Get with the program.. Or kindly Stfu plz
“We know a lot of our players won’t have endless hours to play every day. I want to hear from you — what systems or features would help make Ashes feel rewarding for casual players too? Your feedback is really important as we shape this.” – Steven Sharif
Trolling a forum deliberately and consistently posting false information about Intrepid and the game to provoke an emotional response and disrupt the community is freakn lame ass hell. Maybe you should stop Noanni... Not Cool!!
However, I'd like to point out that the people ar Intrepid that know what they are talking about (ie, those that have made MMO's before) have always asked for feedback, but never suggestions.
Anyone that is actually good in any field understands this. People can inform us of what they do or don't like about what we do, but they have no hope at all of being able to offer up a worthwhile suggestion.
Since Steven is by no means an expert at anything, this is a concept he doesn't understand.
If you have not noticed you have gotten a little out of hand as of late.... I am praying this thread does not reflect your normal input, advice, suggestion and behavior... If it does, dude you screwed! Have fun being unhappy... Till you change..
Cause here's him in August, fed up with all of our amazing and incredible ideas on what Intrepid should do.
https://youtube.com/clip/UgkxIZp0BCTJ3z1wu1cJKJMZtwL66HKn_Jnt?si=7kzIK0D1yFGvg9fA
He doesn't want suggestions or ideas, he simply wants complaints and/or praise.
So kinda missing the mark the mark here brother.... Just because he is requesting specific feedback loop on a massive amount of data they pushed to test, does not mean,,, (I am assuming based on history) they do want Zero suggestions from the community in the Future. In addition to the fact in the same Video, they are "encouraging people to share thier thoughts"
Do not be so sensitive.... and Relax
Excellent job looking at one piece and trying to get it, to fit into a broken false statement about the whole team... I would give it a "B+"
And each time I've referenced this quote, I've always said "Steven doesn't want suggestions, he wants complaints", because I simply take him at his word and that's exactly what he said. He is the final word at the company, so it doesn't matter if the team wants feedback, because Steven is the one making the final decision.
And his decisions have been shit.